ADVERTISEMENT

Kirby Smart laments FSU opt-outs after Georgia's Orange Bowl rout

Halldan1

Moderator
Moderator
Jan 1, 2003
186,813
100,978
113

David Hale, ESPN Staff Writer

MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. -- The two top-ranked teams outside the College Football Playoff faced off in the Capital One Orange Bowl, but only sixth-ranked Georgia looked the part Saturday -- and that led to some frustration from Bulldogs head coach Kirby Smart.

Georgia demolished No. 5 Florida State 63-3 in what was the largest margin of victory in bowl history, topping the Dawgs' 58-point win over TCU in last season's national championship game. But the lopsided score was due, in part at least, to a host of opt-outs and injuries for the Seminoles.

"People need to see what happened tonight, and they need to fix this," Smart said, lamenting the flood of opt-outs and portal entries on teams playing in non-playoff bowl games. "It needs to be fixed. It's very unfortunate that they have a good football team and a good football program, and they're in the position they're in."

The Seminoles played without their top two quarterbacks, top two running backs, top two receivers, starting tight end, three starting defensive linemen, two of three starting linebackers and three starting defensive backs. They were down 29 scholarship players in all.

FSU head coach Mike Norvell strongly intimated that the College Football Playoff committee's decision to leave a 13-0 Seminoles team out of the playoff in favor of two one-loss teams -- Texas and Alabama -- motivated a significant number of his team's opt-outs.

Florida State beat the Louisville Cardinals 16-6 in the ACC championship game with third-string quarterback Brock Glenn at the helm of a lackluster offense, and the committee used that performance -- and the injury to star quarterback Jordan Travis that preceded it -- as rationale for keeping an undefeated Power 5 team from the playoff.

"Every situation is different," Norvell said. "Ours was unique, something that's never happened in college football. Ultimately, I think there was a lot of things that made it extremely challenging. I fully believe that if we would've come up short in the [ACC] championship game, it might've been a little different.

"It was hard choices for a lot of the young men that were on our team. We were hurt. ... When you do the things that our guys did throughout the year and the way that they responded, the way they fought, the way that they just pulled together, it hurt when we were not selected."

Florida State defensive tackle Braden Fiske, who missed the game with a foot injury he said he had been trying to rehab throughout December, said the Seminoles were invested in the Orange Bowl and didn't expect to be blown out. But it was impossible to ignore the sheer volume of missing production from a team that went unbeaten in the regular season.

For his part, Smart said the impact of the opt-outs was notable, and even with an expanded playoff coming next year, the bowls outside the playoff risk becoming glorified scrimmages.

"You can say it's their fault and they have to solve their own problem," Smart said. "We had our guys, and they didn't have their guys. College football has to decide what they want. I know things are changing. But there's still going to be bowl games outside of those. People need to decide what they want and what they want to get out of it, because it's really unfortunate for those kids on that sideline that had to play in that game and didn't have their full arsenal. And it affected the game, 100 percent."

Smart praised his own team's buy-in, which included decisions by a number of key seniors to play. Georgia did not have any official opt-outs, though several stars, including tight end Brock Bowers, missed the game due to injury.

"The game mattered just because, if you're a competitor, then every game matters -- every opportunity you get to go out there and play with people you love," Georgia defensive back Kamari Lassiter said.

Norvell took responsibility for not having his team fully prepared to play Georgia, but he also acknowledged that with so many inexperienced players on the field, FSU fell victim to numerous communication issues and had serious problems with fundamentals and technique.


It's up for debate how different things would've been for the Seminoles with Fiske, Jared Verse, Keon Coleman, Trey Benson and others, but Norvell said he didn't want the final score of the Orange Bowl to be what defined this FSU team.

"Ultimately, this team did all that I asked them to, and they're forever champions," Norvell said. "We went 13 weeks throughout this season, and it's a physical task, especially with what we faced and winning every one of them and rising up, guys that played hurt, guys that played through every different piece of adversity that could be thrown at them.

"When you overcome that and still have a little -- still have the disappointment of not getting to compete for it all, I think that definitely affected some of our situation."
 

ESPN announcer rails against ‘chaos’ of ‘broken’ college football business​

By Caroline McCarthy

ESPN announcer Joe Tessitore had a lot to say after Florida State’s humiliating 63-3 loss to the Georgia Bulldogs on Saturday in the Orange Bowl at Miami Gardens, Fla.

“The business of college football, the infrastructure of college football, is broken,” Tessitore said during the fourth quarter.

The Seminoles were down more than twenty players due to injury, opt-outs and the transfer portal, which Tessitore says is the reason for Florida State’s loss.

“The calendar, where you have the transfer portal, the early signing date, the coaches’ turmoil and silly season of hiring and firing, of players coming and going while you’re trying to bowl prep — that is pure chaos,” Tessitore said.

Georgia lineman Warren Brinson saw the writing on the wall early on, and even went live on Instagram before the game was over

The majority of Florida State starters, including major names such as wide receivers Keon Coleman and Johnny Wilson and defensive lineman Jared Verse, Fabien Lovett and Braden Fiske opted not to play Saturday.

The players made their decisions after the Seminoles were not selected for the College Football Playoff despite having an undefeated season and winning a Power 5 conference championship.

College Football Playoff executive director Bill Hancock explained in a letter addressed to US Senator Rick Scott that the decision was based off of Florida State’s injuries — including the loss of starting quarterback Jordan Travis to an injury in November — and strength of schedule.

In the letter, Hancock wrote that the College Football Playoff committee decided the Seminoles were “not the same team without (their) star quarterback.”

Florida State fans were initially outraged by the decision, but after Saturday’s Orange Bowl blowout to Georgia — which was also left outside the playoffs — the fans may have changed their tune.

The College Football Playoff Committee announced last month that 12 teams will make it to the playoffs for the 2024-2025 season, which the committee hopes will bring more access and excitement for college football fans.

“We’re delighted to be moving forward,” Hancock said. “When the board expanded the playoff beginning in 2026 and asked the CFP Management Committee to examine the feasibility of starting the new format earlier, the Management Committee went right to work.”
 
Do these bowls make money? Until that changes and people stop because the product is so compromised it won't matter.
 
Very simple. Top 8 teams make the playoffs. All other bowl games please just go away. Start the games in early December and end the first week of January.
 
How do you link NIL comp with playing in the bowls? Probably an impossible task until they get their arms around the mess they’ve caused. Tessitore and Smart are right.
 
Do these bowls make money? Until that changes and people stop because the product is so compromised it won't matter.
Pop tarts did well out of this...it is all about ticket allotments and having a full stadium...too many bowls it is watered down
 
Minus the QB scenario at FSU this is not the same roster if they were in the Big 4...they fielded a shell of a roster saturday
 
College football is a disaster. The game is getting destroyed. All that counts is short term money. Sad. College basketball is the best sport by far but can follow a similar path.
 
How do you link NIL comp with playing in the bowls? Probably an impossible task until they get their arms around the mess they’ve caused. Tessitore and Smart are right.
Very simply… revenue share model across all of college sports… ticket sale + TV revenue allotment to the school to disperse to the players as they see fit
 
This article is too funny. Two guys that greatly use the transfer portal and those opt outs complaining about………..opt outs.

College coaches of all sports are so whiny and sanctimonious yet the fans play into it.
 
Outside of Monday night's two games who cares about any other bowl game? The other games have become JV games because of the NFL draft and the Transfer Portal. TV ratings will drop along with the $ associated with them. Our college football is broken and can only be fixed by people inside the sport. We don't need politicians or activists telling us what to do.
 
Outside of Monday night's two games who cares about any other bowl game? The other games have become JV games because of the NFL draft and the Transfer Portal. TV ratings will drop along with the $ associated with them. Our college football is broken and can only be fixed by people inside the sport. We don't need politicians or activists telling us what to do.
Ratings are mostly up this year. The Cotton Bowl scored its best ratings in a decade.

ESPN owns many of the bowls. That means no rights fees and it's controllable content that draws viewers. That's the major reason there are as many bowls as there are.

My thoughts:

First, move the early signing period and the opening of the transfer portal back to January 15 or later -- after the season is over.

Second, the player's NIL arrangement is at least partially contingent on being available through the end of the season unless injured. IF necessary, an independent doctor can be used to make a determination if a player is healthy enough to play.
 
Ratings are mostly up this year. The Cotton Bowl scored its best ratings in a decade.

ESPN owns many of the bowls. That means no rights fees and it's controllable content that draws viewers. That's the major reason there are as many bowls as there are.

My thoughts:

First, move the early signing period and the opening of the transfer portal back to January 15 or later -- after the season is over.

Second, the player's NIL arrangement is at least partially contingent on being available through the end of the season unless injured. IF necessary, an independent doctor can be used to make a determination if a player is healthy enough to play.
Good thoughts.Of course we'll have to get ready for the lawsuits.

The ratings might be up this year as viewers might have tuned in not realizing how badly played most games were because of missing players.Keep that up and viewership will deteriorate over time.Most people are not stupid.
 
Ratings are mostly up this year. The Cotton Bowl scored its best ratings in a decade.

ESPN owns many of the bowls. That means no rights fees and it's controllable content that draws viewers. That's the major reason there are as many bowls as there are.

My thoughts:

First, move the early signing period and the opening of the transfer portal back to January 15 or later -- after the season is over.

Second, the player's NIL arrangement is at least partially contingent on being available through the end of the season unless injured. IF necessary, an independent doctor can be used to make a determination if a player is healthy enough to play.

The independent doctor better have a helluva liability insurance policy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUisNJsTeam
If you really start to take a look at college football, you realize how silly it has become.

6-6 record (and sometime 5-7) gets you in a bowl game.
Players hitting the transfer portal before the bowl game.
Players sitting out the bowl game.
Except for the championship games, nobody really cares who wins or lose the bowl games.
 
If you really start to take a look at college football, you realize how silly it has become.

6-6 record (and sometime 5-7) gets you in a bowl game.
Players hitting the transfer portal before the bowl game.
Players sitting out the bowl game.
Except for the championship games, nobody really cares who wins or lose the bowl games.
Portal calendar what can you do, need to enroll for new school early to mid jan
 
If you really start to take a look at college football, you realize how silly it has become.

6-6 record (and sometime 5-7) gets you in a bowl game.
Players hitting the transfer portal before the bowl game.
Players sitting out the bowl game.
Except for the championship games, nobody really cares who wins or lose the bowl games.
And no one really watches those bowl games with the 5-6, 6-6 and 7-5 teams either. Who the hell is actually making money on those!?
 
Give credit to Bo Nix.He's playing in Fiesta Bowl.Must be a stand up guy.
 
Shame on the collectives. Simple answer is to backload the NIL deal and ensure these young people play in the bowl game before they get paid. These NIL deals are pay for play. But the people putting these deals together are kissing too much player ass. Give them 10% each of the first 3 months and the other 70% when the season is over. See how many players transfer or opt out. A player making $250K gets 25K end of September, another 25K end of October, and another 25K end of November. Anyone think this player is leaving the remaining 175K on the table to opt out or transer?
 
There’s too many BS, meaningless Bowl games. But as long as people watch and TV Ads can be sold for premium this will continue.
 
There’s too many BS, meaningless Bowl games. But as long as people watch and TV Ads can be sold for premium this will continue.
There wouldn't be as many of these games if there were no place to watch them. When you own the content, as ESPN does for many bowls, it's much easier to turn a profit (no media rights to pay such as for the CFP or pro sports).

The NCAA and its conferences aren't going to say no to the media partner that has made the largest investment in its product.

Consider the Pop Tarts bowl which drew an audience of more than 4.3 million viewers in prime time for NC State and Kansas State (neither CFB power houses). That's a lot of eyes for a game which overlapped with an NFL Thursday night game.

Pop Tarts reportedly gained more than $12 million worth of exposure from an investment of $2 million.
 
Shame on the collectives. Simple answer is to backload the NIL deal and ensure these young people play in the bowl game before they get paid. These NIL deals are pay for play. But the people putting these deals together are kissing too much player ass. Give them 10% each of the first 3 months and the other 70% when the season is over. See how many players transfer or opt out. A player making $250K gets 25K end of September, another 25K end of October, and another 25K end of November. Anyone think this player is leaving the remaining 175K on the table to opt out or transer?
Any collective that structured their graft in that fashion would get outbid by an even more unscrupulous collective.
 
Any collective that structured their graft in that fashion would get outbid by an even more unscrupulous collective.
I think you’re right when it comes to guys like Marvin Harrison Jr. but I’m not so sure for the overwhelming majority that’s would be the case. If one school is going to outbid for a player by 50k and structures it that way, I don’t see many taking the lower number so they can transfer before the bowl. These players want the most money.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT