The Giants’ problem is very clear. They get terrible QB play. League-average QB plan and they’re likely 5-5. Far too many mistakes and simply an inability for the player to make the critical plays that determine wins and losses in this day and age. Go down this list this year: Yesterday, Steelers, Bengals, Cowboys, I mean, sometimes it is about 1 player at 1 position when it’s so critical.
You watch the games and it’s overwhelming. Even the numbers are overwhelming now. Look at any of them. How about the fact they’re 3-13 with him the past two seasons, 5-6 without him, LOL. They’re not a great roster yet – need to keep building in secondary and interior DL – but they should be a .500 team.
Paying DJ $40M a year was the decision that should get these guys fired. He has had how many prove it years now? Guys in his 6th season and many league experts continue to be exasperated by the Giants continuing to play him. We've been in QB hell for way too long. Getting an experienced QB would have been a better move if they couldn't draft their guy, but they screwed the pooch. The QB class coming out isn't even close to being as talented as the last one. Penix is better than the QBs coming out this year and he was the 4th QB taken in the draft at #8.
Schoen better pull a rabbit out of the hat if he wants to keep his job. One good draft class out of 3. Facts.
I feel for Daboll but he's getting desperate with his play calling too. That 3rd and 1 and he calls a lateral back to the QB instead of keeping the drive going last week when Tracy was running well at the time. He's lost his mojo and his play calling is no better than Kafka's. The guy executing the plays is terrible. Tommy Cutlets would be better which isn't saying much.
Top to bottom is the talent better on the team than when they inherited it? Can that talent beat anyone in our division? Maybe the Cowboys by a point now that Dak is hurt. We were last place in the division three years ago and will be again. That is the measure that Mara and Tisch should judge them on.
They will probably start another QB and we win a few more games down the stretch pushing us lower in the draft order. Or they will keep playing Jones, he will get hurt and his injury clause will cost us millions in the future salary cap. They've boxed themselves in here. The right move is to sit Jones and keep future cap money. What a mess!
