Ranking the coaches to date

[Halldan1]

1. Smart 16-5 - 8-2
Hard to watch the game Saturday and not have him #1

2. Miller 16-4 8-1
Especially with Miller dropping one to DePaul

3. Cooley 15-5 7-2
Sure they lost 2 of their last three. But both were decent efforts on the road against Creighton and Marquette

4. Hurley 16-5 5-5
Tenuous, but a 30 point blowout even against Butler is impressive

5. McDermott 11-8 5-3
Have they righted the ship

6. Holloway 12-9 5-5
Lookin good Wednesday. Not so much 3 days later

7. Anderson 13-7 3-6
Stinker vs SJU after beating UConn on the road

8. Stubblefield 9-11 3-6
Decent week beating Xavier and then losing a reasonably (11 points )close away game at Providence

9. Neptune 10-10 4-5
Righting the ship? Although a close home win vs Georgetown and the painful to watch victory at MSG are nothing to write home about

10. Matta 11-10 3-7
Losing 2 games by a combined total of 51 points usually would have you #11............

11. Ewing 5-15 0-9
.............but that spot is reserved for the worst streak in Big East history. 30 and counting

 

[MBF72]

No love here for Neptune: for teams in the bottom half, any two wins are impressive.
Neptune at #7.
Huge gap between 5 and 6.

 

[shu09]

1. Smart
2. Miller
3. Cooley
4. Hurley
5. McDermott
6. Holloway
7. Anderson
8. Stubblefield
9. Neptune
10. Matta
11. Ewing

I see it the same way. #1 is clear. #11 is clear. #2-4 can go any way you want but nobody else has a case to be there. #5 and #6 are pretty clear to me. #7-10 can go any which way, nobody doing a great job there.

 

[SPK145]

1 - Smart
2 - Cooley
3 - Miller

4 - Hurley
5 - McDermott

6 - Holloway

7 - Anderson
8 - Stubblefield

9 - Matta
10 - Neptune

11 - Ewing

 

[Bud Boomer]

COY
1. Smart
2. Hurley

Very Good
3. McDermott
4. Miller
5. Cooley

OK
6. Matta
7. Holloway

Bad
8. Anderson
9. Neptune
10. Stubblefield

Just Fire Me Already
11. Ewing

 

[radecicco]

Disagree with Matta over Holloway. He has one good win over K-State in November. That’s it.

 

[Bud Boomer]

Yes I’m aware I’m on a limb with Matta. I have him higher than most because of how bad his roster is, and how bad they were supposed to be.