Colts fake punt a sad reflection of Pagano’s hot seat
By
Bart Hubbuch
October 19, 2015 | 11:12am
Colt Anderson is swallowed up by the Patriots punt return team (right) after Griff Whalen (17) snapped the ball on a woefully designed fake. Photo: AP
It was one of the worst play calls in NFL history, and
the Colts’ decision to try a bizarre fake punt in the third quarter Sunday night didn’t get any better when they tried to explain it.
The Patriots certainly couldn’t contain their laughter after Griff Whalen inexplicably snapped to Colt Anderson on a fourth-down play late in the third quarter, paving the way for a 34-27 New England victory.
Everyone else was just left scratching their heads.
Indianapolis coach Chuck Pagano, after taking nearly 40 minutes before addressing the media, took the blame for what he repeatedly called “miscommunication,” saying the play was mainly intended to draw a penalty on the Patriots.
But it was the Colts who were penalized because their line shift was illegal, and neither Pagano nor Whalen would explain why Whalen — a 190-pound receiver by trade — decided to snap the ball with at least four Patriots directly in his face.
Anderson was instantly swarmed for a 1-yard loss, giving the Patriots the ball at the Indy 35 and setting up a touchdown six plays later that essentially put the game out of reach.
The embarrassment for Pagano only got worse when Colts punter Pat McAfee admitted afterward Indy had started working on that play last year and put it back in the playbook just for the Patriots.
“The look was not there that we normally have in practice when [the fake] is a go,” McAfee said. “There must have been some miscommunication between the snapper and Colt, and it turned out to be one of the most failed fakes probably of all time.”
Colts head coach Chuck PaganoPhoto: Getty Images
The debacle perhaps sealed the fate of Pagano, who is in the last year of his contract and whose job reportedly had been in jeopardy even before his desire to outsmart Bill Belichick ended up burning him.
The Patriots, fuming at the Colts for setting off Deflategate with a complaint to the league in January, couldn’t hide their glee at Indy’s self-inflicted disaster.
“I’m glad they did it,” New England wide receiver Julian Edelman said. “We were alert, and our guys went to where we had to go. Shame on them for trying that again.”
Edelman added a dig at the Colts’ wackiness.
“You’re not surprised with anything [with] how they play,” he said. “They tried the onside kick [Sunday night], and they did that [fake punt]. You know, Colts.”