Maybe it just really comes down to QB play now? With the roster churn and lack of practice time, the league is tremendously sloppy and the % of one-score games has never been higher. It’s all about situational football. The Giants made those plays in 2022. They did not in 2023 and this year.
The Giants rolled out an aged and diminished Eli for too long, then drafted a guy that they were stubborn on developing, unlike teams around the league who dumped bad QB’s fast. The NFL is entirely situational football now. I bet if we charted out QB play over this time frame the Giants would be near last. Bad QB play is a big factor in this sport