Because you are calling the guy a liar. We get that you don’t like police, but there’s no reason to not believe Pirate64, who is hardly a wildly opinionated person on this board. Even when you believe strongly in something, no matter your side, you can’t swing at every pitch and espouse your thoughts every time. Again, I don’t know the man, but from his work on this board (and also for the school) he deserves a little more respect than that. If you don’t believe Pirate64, maybe you might just let it go rather than imply that he’s making up stories. Nothing wrong with casting some niceness towards a fellow Pirate fan, even if that only means resisting hitting the “post reply” button. You’re not obligated to, but there’s nothing wrong with doing that, especially when what brings us here is a shared affinity for SHU basketball and not politics.
One thing that’s pretty clear in these discussions on this board is that nobody is changing their opinion on anything based on what someone posts on Pirate Crew. Some people are (a lot) more emphatic in their views than others. I know I’m not going to get fired up over anyone’s political views here because it’s not worth it. But it’s wrong to publicly question someone’s honesty on a SHU basketball board just because it doesn’t match your political viewpoint.