ADVERTISEMENT

Debate Questions

HALL85

All Universe
Gold Member
Jul 5, 2001
36,870
20,349
113
Why nothing about
- Foreign policy
- Terrorism - ISIS, etc.
- Illegal immigration - Path to citizenship
- Gun control

Do Americans not care about these issues?
Did Trump effectively address them because they are non-issues now?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
Why nothing about
- Foreign policy
- Terrorism - ISIS, etc.
- Illegal immigration - Path to citizenship
- Gun control

Do Americans not care about these issues?
Did Trump effectively address them because they are non-issues now?
VP GAME THREAD, DING DING DING

man this is so much more enjoyable. two people who have some sort of life under their skin. and no yelling. of course i hate both of them. theyre both doing well if you dont count the straight lying both of them are accusing each other of.
 
Also, the facial expressions by both when the other is speaking are terrible.
 
pence is clearly trying to say what trump would say if he was and adult. either that or he has his nose sewn tight to dons buttcheeks. i honestly never really heard this guy talk before.

i thought id be more annoyed by kamala
 
pence completely avoided the trump healthcare plan at all costs. people might hate obamacare, but its better than having absolutely nothing, no plan. no plan would be a disaster. and thats exactly what trump has. healthcare means a lot to me and they have no idea wtf theyre doing with it.

pence had the gall to tell kamala she was deflecting in the middle of his very own deflection. clown show again. but hey got a few mins out of it.

kamala is now turning into a theatrical storyteller. and since the questions are about the stinking police topics its becoming annoying.
 
Is Obamacare about health care or health insurance?

The Obamacare plans are so expensive with huge deductibles, are people actually using them? Is there more health care or does this just check the box on having more people with insurance but not actually using it?

I need Merge to do some research on this, he’s good at this type of stuff.
 
Is Obamacare about health care or health insurance?

The Obamacare plans are so expensive with huge deductibles, are people actually using them? Is there more health care or does this just check the box on having more people with insurance but not actually using it?

I need Merge to do some research on this, he’s good at this type of stuff.
i have a healthcare.gov plan with a 0 deductible. i get a tax credit on it, essentially pay half the plan. its better than having to shell for the full plan, which i will have to assume is the alternative option... since there is no plan.

if you think its expensive try paying for the insurance plan straight up
 
i have a healthcare.gov plan with a 0 deductible. i get a tax credit on it, essentially pay half the plan. its better than having to shell for the full plan, which i will have to assume is the alternative option... since there is no plan.

if you think its expensive try paying for the insurance plan straight up

Can I see that plan? What state?
 
Is Obamacare about health care or health insurance?

The Obamacare plans are so expensive with huge deductibles, are people actually using them? Is there more health care or does this just check the box on having more people with insurance but not actually using it?

I need Merge to do some research on this, he’s good at this type of stuff.
SPK you are a business entrepreneur right?

What we have seen in last 6 months is that, health insurance is tied to employment. Company cuts you, you lose their coverage if you opting in and only a federal statute is reason you can then have 18 months of COBRA, so one can lose their job through no fault of their own and then get extorted by COBRA up until they can go find a plan at healthcare.gov website for open enrollment.

If you have family, kids, a mortage, car payment, state unemployment and even the extra 600 fed that was given for a finite window not helping in long run. I know people should have been in a field where they dont get fired.

Sadly in the US the better your health insurance, the pricier it is, the better chance you will be seen by a top tier health care professional.

Yes I understand that medical professionals and particular specialists do years of study and mega hours of internship and practical experience to get their degrees and practice and its an expensive project investment and they do deserve to make a good living.

A lot of general practioners just want to load up on patients 3 to 4 days a week and offer them scripts.

If what I know now I knew 20 years ago, I would have gone to school for health sciences and then go for a doctor of chiropractic care degree. At 25 and 26 you are out and getting a chance to improve people's quality of life.
 
Both dodged questions, but it was a civil, substantive debate. Pretty much a draw, both had good and bad moments.

What was clear to me is that both are smooth, savvy politicians. They play the game well. Despite that, I wish they were heading their respective tickets. I'd vote for Harris before Biden and Pence before Trump.
 
SPK you are a business entrepreneur right?

What we have seen in last 6 months is that, health insurance is tied to employment. Company cuts you, you lose their coverage if you opting in and only a federal statute is reason you can then have 18 months of COBRA, so one can lose their job through no fault of their own and then get extorted by COBRA up until they can go find a plan at healthcare.gov website for open enrollment.

If you have family, kids, a mortage, car payment, state unemployment and even the extra 600 fed that was given for a finite window not helping in long run. I know people should have been in a field where they dont get fired.

Sadly in the US the better your health insurance, the pricier it is, the better chance you will be seen by a top tier health care professional.

Yes I understand that medical professionals and particular specialists do years of study and mega hours of internship and practical experience to get their degrees and practice and its an expensive project investment and they do deserve to make a good living.

A lot of general practioners just want to load up on patients 3 to 4 days a week and offer them scripts.

If what I know now I knew 20 years ago, I would have gone to school for health sciences and then go for a doctor of chiropractic care degree. At 25 and 26 you are out and getting a chance to improve people's quality of life.

Where were you years ago when I ranted here about health insurance being tied to your job? It’s not a good model. It’s also why I knew Obama lied when he said if you like your insurance, you can keep your insurance.

Untying health insurance from employment though brings health insurance back to a personal responsibility, that’s what I’m all about, but far too many (possibly/probably even you, no disrespect) have issues with that.

Health insurance and health care are responsibilities, not god-given rights (shu09 won’t like that part, I offend everyone). Bring the cost curve for insurance and care down, give some help to the truly indigent.
 
Can I see that plan? What state?
Pennsylvania. there are high premium, low premium, high deductible, no deductible, ppos, hmos. they all have some sort of pro and con. all together im pretty annoyed by the hmo plan and the service of IBX but its better than paying for the whole plan privately.

you get a tax credit depending on your income or means. i pay around $300/month for a 0 deduc hmo plan. the options arent tthe best mostly because the actual insurance site has 5 yr outdated provider plan so you dont actually know who you can go to. its a headache but on the provider side. thats the pro con. pro = 0 deduc con =hmo and having to do that song and dance with the different tiers and referrels. beat city.

ive also dont new york which wasnt that bad. tax credit was higher. plan was a ppo i think. dont remember the deduc. i dont pick plans with high deduc because its basically not having insurance.
 
Is Obamacare about health care or health insurance?

The Obamacare plans are so expensive with huge deductibles, are people actually using them? Is there more health care or does this just check the box on having more people with insurance but not actually using it?

I need Merge to do some research on this, he’s good at this type of stuff.
Funny that most people tend to ignore that fact. The ACA has failed on many levels, primarily because politicians are too stupid and don’t have the fortitude to follow through.

it was sold as an exercise in “bending the curve”, but essentially it became a cost shift and under the guise of providing access. The problem is most of the taxes that were part of the plan have never been instituted. So what happened? Prescription drug prices and the cost of the actual care continued to spike up over the past seven years. Pharma, med device, insurance companies and attorneys have done extremely well since it was instituted. The public has ended up footing the bill. Access does it mean anything if you can’t afford the rising out of pocket costs.

there is no elegant way to move to a free market concepts with price transparency and competition. No politician in their right mind is going to step on that third rail right now. Which is why Trump keeps kicking the can down the road as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
Where were you years ago when I ranted here about health insurance being tied to your job? It’s not a good model. It’s also why I knew Obama lied when he said if you like your insurance, you can keep your insurance.

Untying health insurance from employment though brings health insurance back to a personal responsibility, that’s what I’m all about, but far too many (possibly/probably even you, no disrespect) have issues with that.

Health insurance and health care are responsibilities, not god-given rights (shu09 won’t like that part, I offend everyone). Bring the cost curve for insurance and care down, give some help to the truly indigent.
How do you suppose you accomplish bringing the insurance and care down? Like someone else said in this thread, Obamacare is better than no plan which is what it was before and what Trump offers. Obamacare May not be perfect. But it’s something that can made better. It’s a good foundation to build on.

I have great health insurance and gave up raises in order to have health coverage for life. I don’t want to give that up. So I was not in favor of Medicare for all. Very happy with Biden’s plan.
 
Why nothing about
- Foreign policy
- Terrorism - ISIS, etc.
- Illegal immigration - Path to citizenship
- Gun control

Do Americans not care about these issues?
Did Trump effectively address them because they are non-issues now?

I find these debates torturous. Harris is all over the map on policy; for fracking, not for fracking, likes Green New Deal, won't implement Green New Deal. And you know if the GOP ramps through a Supreme Court justice on top of what they did to Garland the Dems are adding justices. Pence comes off as a total phony to me, I really learn nothing new. This new line that if H1N1 was as lethal as COVID-19 it would be even worse than now (while he's behind plexiglass BTW) is also mind boggling to me. That's your defense? Holy cow.

And on healthcare, have Trump/Pence proposed what they would do yet? It's 4 years in. Maybe I missed it.

The format is a train wreck, IMO. They select too many topics and jump through them with very little accountability, then don't even cover a lot of things people want to know about. The format also encourages dodging because you just run the clock to the next topic.

And what does it matter? Maybe it meant more in times past when the media was different. But nowadays the news cycles are so fast it does little to move the needle. Little staying power... Well, other than the fly on Pence's head, lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
How do you suppose you accomplish bringing the insurance and care down? Like someone else said in this thread, Obamacare is better than no plan which is what it was before and what Trump offers. Obamacare May not be perfect. But it’s something that can made better. It’s a good foundation to build on.

I have great health insurance and gave up raises in order to have health coverage for life. I don’t want to give that up. So I was not in favor of Medicare for all. Very happy with Biden’s plan.
Why is the ACA better? It’s not like we had nothing before it was implemented (and it hasn’t even been fully implemented).
 
Why is the ACA better? It’s not like we had nothing before it was implemented (and it hasn’t even been fully implemented).
I am at a company that uses CIGNA, for all seasonal people that are hired which is a span of 24 to 32 weeks of full time employment, the CIGNA ACA plan is offered. It is terrible. It is better to pay out of pocket a little more per month through healthcare.gov....the issue here though is that Obamacare aimed to bring coverage to all...yes agree it has not been fully implemented...here is big issue as we start entering open enrollment in a few weeks, job market is slashed, wages are down, health coverage monthly premiums going up
 
I am at a company that uses CIGNA, for all seasonal people that are hired which is a span of 24 to 32 weeks of full time employment, the CIGNA ACA plan is offered. It is terrible. It is better to pay out of pocket a little more per month through healthcare.gov....the issue here though is that Obamacare aimed to bring coverage to all...yes agree it has not been fully implemented...here is big issue as we start entering open enrollment in a few weeks, job market is slashed, wages are down, health coverage monthly premiums going up
Which is why opening up competition will open more options are lower costs to the consumer. Why should those employees be limited to two crappy choices?
 
I find these debates torturous. Harris is all over the map on policy; for fracking, not for fracking, likes Green New Deal, won't implement Green New Deal. And you know if the GOP ramps through a Supreme Court justice on top of what they did to Garland the Dems are adding justices. Pence comes off as a total phony to me, I really learn nothing new. This new line that if H1N1 was as lethal as COVID-19 it would be even worse than now (while he's behind plexiglass BTW) is also mind boggling to me. That's your defense? Holy cow.

And on healthcare, have Trump/Pence proposed what they would do yet? It's 4 years in. Maybe I missed it.

The format is a train wreck, IMO. They select too many topics and jump through them with very little accountability, then don't even cover a lot of things people want to know about. The format also encourages dodging because you just run the clock to the next topic.

And what does it matter? Maybe it meant more in times past when the media was different. But nowadays the news cycles are so fast it does little to move the needle. Little staying power... Well, other than the fly on Pence's head, lol.
Your expectations were too high...lol. It would be too easy to ask what their plan for the next four years would be on each issue. These debates are designed for entertainment and ratings. No one answers the questions and it doesn’t move the needle.
I thought Pence’s best line was that Biden’s COVID plan was essentially Trumps plan. Harris whiffed on that, but it all doesn’t matter.
 
Which is why opening up competition will open more options are lower costs to the consumer. Why should those employees be limited to two crappy choices?
You really wanna use the term employee on them? It is more like time share mercenaries.

The healthcare.gov options are potentially good dependent upon which state one reside's in. The core premise of obamacare was well intended, actually exection and x's and o's complete mess.

Cost vs quality of whats provided is a big deal now and going forward. I think in an individual plan a reasonable deductibible if spending 400 to 500 a month should be a 2k cap. If married 4k cap, if we kids 6k cap. But we dont have that now and its going up not down in 4 weeks.
 
i have a healthcare.gov plan with a 0 deductible. i get a tax credit on it, essentially pay half the plan. its better than having to shell for the full plan, which i will have to assume is the alternative option... since there is no plan.

if you think its expensive try paying for the insurance plan straight up
Why must the government have anything other than Medicare and Medicaid? Maybe expand govt care if ins cos drop u because of pre-existing conditions.
 
Btw in the United States everything is designed to be more expensive once a person is beyond a threshhold health and wellness wise.

Your diet is garbage, you dont exercise, here is a script for blood pressure, here is a script for cholesterol. Oh these medicines made your sugar raise. Here is a script for insulin. Oh the supplemental insulin you are now providing to your body because other medications you ingested caused your insulin production to stop working has now made your sed rate and c reactive protein levels abnormally high, here have this script. Oh you cant sleep well anymore, here is another script.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu09
Btw in the United States everything is designed to be more expensive once a person is beyond a threshhold health and wellness wise.

Your diet is garbage, you dont exercise, here is a script for blood pressure, here is a script for cholesterol. Oh these medicines made your sugar raise. Here is a script for insulin. Oh the supplemental insulin you are now providing to your body because other medications you ingested caused your insulin production to stop working has now made your sed rate and c reactive protein levels abnormally high, here have this script. Oh you cant sleep well anymore, here is another script.
take responsibility for your own health
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu09
You really wanna use the term employee on them? It is more like time share mercenaries.

The healthcare.gov options are potentially good dependent upon which state one reside's in. The core premise of obamacare was well intended, actually exection and x's and o's complete mess.

Cost vs quality of whats provided is a big deal now and going forward. I think in an individual plan a reasonable deductibible if spending 400 to 500 a month should be a 2k cap. If married 4k cap, if we kids 6k cap. But we dont have that now and its going up not down in 4 weeks.
The core premise of the ACA changed in mid-stream. It was poorly conceived and poorly executed. A lot of smart people profited from it. But as some would say... “it wasn’t perfect “....no sh_t.
 
Btw in the United States everything is designed to be more expensive once a person is beyond a threshhold health and wellness wise.

Your diet is garbage, you dont exercise, here is a script for blood pressure, here is a script for cholesterol. Oh these medicines made your sugar raise. Here is a script for insulin. Oh the supplemental insulin you are now providing to your body because other medications you ingested caused your insulin production to stop working has now made your sed rate and c reactive protein levels abnormally high, here have this script. Oh you cant sleep well anymore, here is another script.

This is the problem in America. Big pharma loves to push pills on people. If people would just take responsibility for their own health (eat well, exercise, get enough sleep), there would be far fewer chronic conditions.
 
This is the problem in America. Big pharma loves to push pills on people. If people would just take responsibility for their own health (eat well, exercise, get enough sleep), there would be far fewer chronic conditions.
Big pharma likes to wine and dine doctors as incentive to push their products on the doctors' patients
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUSA and shu09
Untying health insurance from employment though brings health insurance back to a personal responsibility, that’s what I’m all about, but far too many (possibly/probably even you, no disrespect) have issues with that.

I have a hard time with the personal responsibility angle with healthcare and am more inclined to believe access to healthcare is more of a social contract among all citizens.

Some of this is absolutely about personal responsibility, but I struggle with those who get sick at no fault of their own. Removing insurance coverage from employment would mean the people who are buying insurance are really only the people who need insurance. Healthy people would leave the pool which would increase the costs dramatically for those who are sick.

Would it really be under "personal responsibility" when there are two families that are neighbors, one is healthy but the other has a child that gets leukemia. The healthy family doesn't buy insurance because they don't need it, but the other family is going to get hit with a gigantic expense. That just seems wrong.

I agree healthcare should not be tied to your employer, but I also believe the system really only works if everyone is required to be in the pool with a basic level of health coverage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cernjSHU
I have a hard time with the personal responsibility angle with healthcare and am more inclined to believe access to healthcare is more of a social contract among all citizens.

Some of this is absolutely about personal responsibility, but I struggle with those who get sick at no fault of their own. Removing insurance coverage from employment would mean the people who are buying insurance are really only the people who need insurance. Healthy people would leave the pool which would increase the costs dramatically for those who are sick.

Would it really be under "personal responsibility" when there are two families that are neighbors, one is healthy but the other has a child that gets leukemia. The healthy family doesn't buy insurance because they don't need it, but the other family is going to get hit with a gigantic expense. That just seems wrong.

I agree healthcare should not be tied to your employer, but I also believe the system really only works if everyone is required to be in the pool with a basic level of health coverage.
I don’t follow that logic. Most people are going to opt in to a healthcare insurance plan to protect themselves from catastrophic bills. Why would the parents who are healthy with healthy kids not participate in a plan? You can opt out of your companies plan if you want to now.

No one can predict those uncontrollable health episodes which is all the more reason to have catastrophic coverage options.

Once again, this is an insurance discussion ( how to pay) and we keep ignoring the actual cost drivers.
 
Why must the government have anything other than Medicare and Medicaid? Maybe expand govt care if ins cos drop u because of pre-existing conditions.
i technically have preexisting conditions, nothing absurd. idk where the line is drawn but i dont remember being asked when signing up.

the govt got involved to slash my price in half. so far that seems to be how its worked for me
 
This is the problem in America. Big pharma loves to push pills on people. If people would just take responsibility for their own health (eat well, exercise, get enough sleep), there would be far fewer chronic conditions.
i think gen pop look to doctors as guidance. doctors dont really get involved with your diet kr sleep patterns. they want you taking pills. i know of a guy just like nyshore described in his example. there is a point where people rely on doctors. everyone is responsible for their health but there is a big responsibility on doctors too.
 
This is the problem in America. Big pharma loves to push pills on people. If people would just take responsibility for their own health (eat well, exercise, get enough sleep), there would be far fewer chronic conditions.
The core of the problem is if the government really cared about healthcare, 75% of the things we eat wouldn't be allowed on the shelves. Something that could sit on the shelf for 6 months and not perish is probably not something you want to put in your body. And if you do, common sense it's going to do more harm than good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu09 and SHUSA
I don’t follow that logic. Most people are going to opt in to a healthcare insurance plan to protect themselves from catastrophic bills

I disagree. People opt-in to the plans now due to expectation and ease. Younger and healthier people would be much more likely to skip it altogether and less responsible people will skip getting insurance until they need it, or not get it at all and go bankrupt because of a hospital bill. I think we can do better.

Once again, this is an insurance discussion ( how to pay) and we keep ignoring the actual cost drivers.

Not really ignoring that. I think the first step is figuring out what the ideal system looks like and then work towards developing that system with considerations for how to pay for it and add how people get and pay for their care.
 
The core of the problem is if the government really cared about healthcare, 75% of the things we eat wouldn't be allowed on the shelves. Something that could sit on the shelf for 6 months and not perish is probably not something you want to put in your body. And if you do, common sense it's going to do more harm than good.
10x like. the amount of preservatives and processed foods out there is whats contributing to all our health problems.

western diet in many avenues is a plague.

so cook fresh, well who has time in our 100hr work week society to cook? so eat organic, well who can afford that?

the roots go deep.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: shu09
Obamacare would have been more effective if politics did not get in the way (ok absurd statement I know). They picked winners and losers. Unions didn't have to participate. Congress and Senate didn't have to participate and so on. Only way to get more younger folks in the pool was to mandate it for all and that is most likely unconstitutional. It's basic premise was off from the start. Something has to be done as the cost is simply too high. Improve ACA or come up with another plan but both parties continue to try and put lipstick on a pig and have not addressed the problem. And state by state insurance regulators have not helped the problem either creating an additional layer of regulations and roadblocks and offering nothing to improve access.

Overall watching the debate was better than the Presidential debate. Both are skilled politicians and handled themselves well. Rarely answered the moderators questions but got their talking points across. I thought Kamala won the Covid discussion easily and Pence won the economy discussion easily.
Disappointed as well that there was little or no foreign policy discussion.
 
i think gen pop look to doctors as guidance. doctors dont really get involved with your diet kr sleep patterns. they want you taking pills. i know of a guy just like nyshore described in his example. there is a point where people rely on doctors. everyone is responsible for their health but there is a big responsibility on doctors too.

That's a problem! If a doctor is not advising you to live healthy and instead pushing pills on you, you shouldn't go to that doctor.
 
The core of the problem is if the government really cared about healthcare, 75% of the things we eat wouldn't be allowed on the shelves. Something that could sit on the shelf for 6 months and not perish is probably not something you want to put in your body. And if you do, common sense it's going to do more harm than good.

Yup.
 
10x like. the amount if preservatives and processed foods out there is whats contributing to all our health problems.

western diet in many avenues is a plague.

so cook fresh, well who has time in our 100hr work week society to cook? so eat organic, well who can afford that?

the roots go deep.

I don't know why people work such crazy hours. Personally, I've never worked more than my standard schedule except on rare occasions. Even that would be maybe 45-50 hours in a week and once in a blue moon.

Organic food is a little more expensive but it's not like it's affordable, you're mischaracterizing it.
 
That's a problem! If a doctor is not advising you to live healthy and instead pushing pills on you, you shouldn't go to that doctor.
easier said than done. your insurance only allows you to go to a subset of doctors. sometimes you need a referral if its a specialist. if you have a pressing need you cant exactly just switch doctors. maybe you do need that medicine or that surgery. who wants to go another 2-3 months not addressing their problem? picking a good doctor is a total crapshoot esp if you have no reccos from friends or family. online ratings are turning into yelp. everyone gets a gold star.

ive found one doctor who has actually addressed diet and exercise as part of a healing regiment, in addition to medicine.hes pretty big time. i also had a separate very esteemed doctor at NYU claim that guy was a homeopathic cook. that made it clear to me that "find another doctor" is a needle in a haystack. to me they all seem like brainwashed pill pushers. besides the original dr, no doctor seems concerned with actually discovering the root of the issue.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT