Enough is Enough: The Leadership Failures at Seton Hall

[jcalz88]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

 

[newshu1]

Wow sounds like Hank Alessandra is a sheep in wolf's clothing?

 

[HALL85]

 

[shupat08]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

Don't criticize Hank! He's going to sic his buddies on this site to attack you!

 

[JTSHU]

Shaheen will be gone in a few years and not because hell be fired or doesnt want to be here. Its for his sanity and his career in coaching

 

[dehere23]

Shaheen will be gone in a few years and not because hell be fired or doesnt want to be here. Its for his sanity and his career in coaching

Really don't see Sha going anywhere. He's like the one guy I feel confident in saying that about, much like I never thought Ewing would leave Georgetown for another college job if he had options.

But to your point, it is no coincidence that "coaches coaches" like Pitino and Smart went out of their way to speak up for and defend Sha the past few weeks. Most of these guys are part of the same fraternity and ultimately stick together. The stuff that bothers fans about opposing coaches is usually not shared by the actual coaches.

 

[bornApirate]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

While I am not considered a massive donor we almost should start making donation pledges that will not be fulfilled until certain changes are made. The lack of forward thinking and lack of willingness to adapt are incredibly frustrating.

 

[dehere23]

While I am not considered a massive donor we almost should start making donation pledges that will not be fulfilled until certain changes are made. The lack of forward thinking and lack of willingness to adapt are incredibly frustrating.

Problem with that is how do you even do so unless it's tied to hiring or firing someone in admin or on the staff.

No donor is going to tell Sha who to play or recruit, and if they did he would (rightfully) tell them where to go with that.

At the same time, look where and how the money was spent this year

 

[The Crows Nest]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

Coming from you…. Adds weight to this sentiments which many have felt. Sobering…I agree, But is there hope that they actually reverse so many years of ineptitude and turn this around?

 

[The Crows Nest]

Really don't see Sha going anywhere. He's like the one guy I feel confident in saying that about, much like I never thought Ewing would leave Georgetown for another college job if he had options.

But to your point, it is no coincidence that "coaches coaches" like Pitino and Smart went out of their way to speak up for and defend Sha the past few weeks. Most of these guys are part of the same fraternity and ultimately stick together. The stuff that bothers fans about opposing coaches is usually not shared by the actual coaches.

Big difference between Ewing and Sha…Ewing took over the team to basically “save” his beloved Alma mater; Sha wants to coach…period. Sure, he would love for it to happen here and for him to succeed here…but if it doesn’t, I firmly believe he moves on to another coaching job…unlike Ewing…or Mullin for that matter

 

[dehere23]

Big difference between Ewing and Sha…Ewing took over the team to basically “save” his beloved Alma mater; Sha wants to coach…period. Sure, he would love for it to happen here and for him to succeed here…but if it doesn’t, I firmly believe he moves on to another coaching job…unlike Ewing…or Mullin for that matter

Ewing was a real coach though. He was a NBA assistant for years. You don’t do that as Patrick Ewing if you don’t want to coach.

I think ultimately he wanted a NBA job.

 

[NittanyPirate]

Just the fact that MANY posters on this board knew what was going to happen to SHU/college bball 2-3 years ago but those in charge weren’t willing to adapt or accept it is frustrating.
I don’t like what has happened. But I also don’t like rooting for a cellar dweller. I don’t have $ to change it. Disappointing times

 

[JoePeppitone2012]

I’m conflicted.

I’m impressed with the new practice facility the funds for that and investing in SHU basketball. I’m happy we pay Sha a fair salary.

But……..I’m beyond disappointed in just about everything else being done by the Board of Regents and Athletic Department.

I hesitate to give one more season because of revenue sharing and the completion of the practice facility. It feels foolish to wait another season again as I have the last 2-3 years with the SHU NIL configuration for some optimism in the basketball program. The hiring of Msgr Reilly has thrown an uncomfortable wrench into all of this.

I also don’t see Bryan Felt and company turning into the next Billy Beane anytime soon

 

[bornApirate]

Problem with that is how do you even do so unless it's tied to hiring or firing someone in admin or on the staff.

No donor is going to tell Sha who to play or recruit, and if they did he would (rightfully) tell them where to go with that.

At the same time, look where and how the money was spent this year

Personally I think the entire BOR needs to go from a university standpoint and the entire assistant coaching staff needs to be replaced. My propasal is along the lines those two things happen I will not give another dollar to the school or NIL. If those changes happen I would commit X dollars. I believe in Sha and think he is the right person for the job, but I believe he is too loyal to certain people. I won’t further on the University admin because that is beyond frustrating.

 

[lloyde dobler]

Personally I think the entire BOR needs to go from a university standpoint and the entire assistant coaching staff needs to be replaced. My propasal is along the lines those two things happen I will not give another dollar to the school or NIL. If those changes happen I would commit X dollars. I believe in Sha and think he is the right person for the job, but I believe he is too loyal to certain people. I won’t further on the University admin because that is beyond frustrating.

Assistant coaches get a lot of unnecessary blame on this board. Quick: Name the staffs at any of the other Big East schools. You can’t. It’s a coaches league, not a coaching staff league.

 

[The Crows Nest]

Ewing was a real coach though. He was a NBA assistant for years. You don’t do that as Patrick Ewing if you don’t want to coach.

I think ultimately he wanted a NBA job.

Might be, my only point is Sha envisions himself as a career college coach; Ewing did not

 

[bornApirate]

Assistant coaches get a lot of unnecessary blame on this board. Quick: Name the staffs at any of the other Big East schools. You can’t. It’s a coaches league, not a coaching staff league.

There needs to be a change. Sha is a defensive minded coach. That does not work in modern CBB. He either needs to bring in a coach who knows an offense or he needs to go as well.

 

[lloyde dobler]

There needs to be a change. Sha is a defensive minded coach. That does not work in modern CBB. He either needs to bring in a coach who knows an offense or he needs to go as well.

That’s a lot different than saying the whole assistant coaching staff needs to be replaced. But even that… how many teams have such a guy? It might seem to make sense, but all across the sport, it’s all about the head coach.

 

[dehere23]

There needs to be a change. Sha is a defensive minded coach. That does not work in modern CBB. He either needs to bring in a coach who knows an offense or he needs to go as well.

Agree with Lloyd that its principally about the HC nowadays. In the past, "recruiters" were needed too especially if that wasn't the strength of the HC, but with NIL that's been mooted to some extent, perhaps a large one for some schools.

Sure, you hear about the impact a Luke Murray had on Hurley from an offensive scheme standpoint, but it's still mostly about the HC.

For a defensive-minded coach, we've been pretty horrific this year from a defensive standpoint.

 

[Halldan1]

Conference-only defense

Kenpom

10 Seton Hall

 

[jack 1970]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

Agree that program is in the dumpster and current athletic/University leadership has to take responsibility for that .We have a tradition of sleepy leadership at SHU.But who's going to step up or come in to fix that?I don't have confidence that we are capable of doing that in a very much changed environment.We're in a very bad place right now.

 

[garyshu71]

Wow…. just like that the thread goes from demanding the resignation of the Chairman of the Board to firing lowly assistant basketball coaches. I wonder who’s going first?? ADHD at work here?

 

[SPK145]

So where does Seton Hall go from here?

 

[HallX2]

Last year, I wrote a post that called out Seton Halls administration from athletics to the executive side, for their complete lack of direction when it comes to NIL. I warned that if we did not act immediately, we would be left behind, and that many in the old guard simply werent up to the task.

Unfortunately, everything I predicted is playing out in real time.

Our NIL program is in shambles, and the consequences are showing on the basketball court. Seton Hall has fallen behind in an area that now defines success in college athletics. While other programs adapt, we remain stagnant, crippled by a leadership group unwilling or incapable of making the necessary changes. The failure to prioritize NIL isnt just a missed opportunity; it’s a direct blow to the future of Seton Hall basketball.

But now, the problem extends beyond NIL. The same leadership failures that have hurt our athletic programs are now on full display at the highest levels of the university. The appointment of Monsignor Joseph Riley as president is a disaster, and the responsibility for this mess falls squarely on the chairman of the Board of Regents, Hank D’Alessandro, and the rest of the board.

The fact that Seton Hall allowed this appointment to happen then doubled and tripled down in defending it is disgraceful. It reflects a lack of foresight, a lack of leadership, and a complete misunderstanding of the current climate in higher education. This isnt about personal politics or ideology; its about competence. And what we’re seeing from our universities leadership is anything but competent.

Seton Hall continues to make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Instead of strengthening our athletic department and modernizing the university, we are stuck in a cycle of self-inflicted wounds caused by outdated, out-of-touch decision-makers. This could have and should have been avoided.

At this point, it’s clear: we need change, and we need it now.

I am calling for the immediate resignation of Hank D’Alessandro as chairman of the Board of Regents. His leadership has been an unmitigated failure, and his decision to stand behind Monsignor Riley proves that he is not fit to guide this university forward.


Seton Hall deserves better. The alumni, the students, the athletes, the donors we deserve leadership that is capable, forward-thinking, and willing to make tough decisions for the betterment of the university. Right now, we do not have that.

Change doesn't happen unless we demand it. I, for one, am demanding it.

Why are we in this position ?

some of your post is right. Much of it not.

 

[SPK145]

some of your post is right. Much of it not.

So elaborate on it then.

 

[Seton75]

i am as big a change the subject offender as anyone. but lots of persons i consider serious and knowledgable supporters of Seton Hall are on this thread and it would be interesting to just discuss jcalz's post.

 

[JTSHU]

Really don't see Sha going anywhere. He's like the one guy I feel confident in saying that about, much like I never thought Ewing would leave Georgetown for another college job if he had options.

But to your point, it is no coincidence that "coaches coaches" like Pitino and Smart went out of their way to speak up for and defend Sha the past few weeks. Most of these guys are part of the same fraternity and ultimately stick together. The stuff that bothers fans about opposing coaches is usually not shared by the actual coaches.

However if out NIL continues to lag behind hes gotta think about his coaching career. If we catch up then im not worried

 

[newshu1]

You can still find dogs with a lower budget though, this NIL is just a cop out. How many major conference teams are there? now how many major mins are avail? There are guys out there who want to showcase talent on a bigger stage. Focus there and not crying about money

 

[radecicco]

You can still find dogs with a lower budget though, this NIL is just a cop out. How many major conference teams are there? now how many major mins are avail? There are guys out there who want to showcase talent on a bigger stage. Focus there and not crying about money

Well, the favorite phrase around here lately is that two things can be true. You’re right there are guys out there who we should be targeting at lower cost who can play. But you have to have $$$ to bring in proven guys that coach can build an offense around.

 

[SHUSA]

you predicted it. anyone with a pulse saw this coming for shu. and here it is. for the most part seton hall has been a clown school. the reilly stuff is clown school again. and you have people on this board defending him last week.

wonder if this thread will be deleted like Felts.