ADVERTISEMENT

Lavin Comments

There has been five years of disappointment, and the sixth year is not complete. No need to to go crazy here making Willard anything more than a coach who has gotten talented players to buy in for part of one season. Love to see it continue and will compliment him accordingly when the season is over. I have seen too many midyear collapses from this team.
 
See, I come at it from the opposite direction. He was my first choice when I hired him, and I was a staunch defender well into his fifth season, even as the opinion of many posters changed with the breeze. I say you support a guy (or don't) until it's clear that he doesn't merit that support anymore.

Last year, I was finally forced to concede I had been wrong. It was plainly evident that he was not as good of a coach as I had believed, so my belief was that he should've been let go last year. Now, just as I never changed my mind with the direction of the wind in the first five seasons, I'm not easily swayed now. I don't think coaches just learn how to coach all of a sudden. And there are just too many variables that make the record alone a clear indicator of a coach's ability. Is our record terrific this year? Obviously, and the team is very good. I'm on record here as saying we can, with the right matchups and a few breaks, contend for the Elite Eight. But when our record sucked in 2012-13, I also still contended - loudly - that this guy was a good coach, and that the record alone did not prove otherwise to me. Then, as now, there are too many other factors and variables that told me there was more to consider than just the wins and losses. But as seasons stack up, and I have more and more data to inform my opinion, I realized I had been wrong about what he brings as a head coach. And I haven't seen what I need to see to change my mind. Perhaps if he's still here in four years, and these kinds of seasons (or something similar) have been sustained even as players cycle through the program, I'll again admit I had it wrong. But right now, the scales are still tilted pretty heavily to one side.

Isaiah Whitehead is, right now, playing better than I've ever seen a Seton Hall player play. He's is what we thought he would be, and he is really put the team on his back. Couple that with the sturdy and stabilizing leadership Derrick Gordon brought to the team - I think he literally saved the season after that first Creighton game, when things looked ready to implode again, and there was no Sterling Gibbs to blame. Without his stabilizing presence (to say nothing of the gritty defense tone he set from day one), I'm not sure this team would have been in the position to allow Whitehead to blossom like he has over the past month. Yeah, kids got a year older and all that, but we've seen kids get older for years and never seen a team grow in this same way - even teams led by this head coach. If I was Kevin Willard, I make a spot for Derrick Gordon on the staff next year. He's shown me that much.

So that's where I am with it. I've been careful not to take potshots at the coach this season, even though I do not support him, or piss on threads congratulating him for this or that. He's here for now, and that's that. Wouldn't have been my call, but no one asked me. But there was a post or two last night calling out the silence of the Willard detractors, and I guess I'm identified as one, so here it is for me. This is what I think. It's not really my way to stomp on a win - and of course I want us to win! - so what was I going to say about him last night? I'm also not trying to swim upstream, and there's no point being one of those jerks who can't let it go, and instead makes every post a vehicle for disparaging the coach. But as I said, I'm rooted in my convictions, and I don't change my mind on a coach back and forth over the course of a season, so it would be silly of me to take a posture of reconsideration when I have not changed my mind. We're having a great season, and I'm thrilled. Give the coach a parade? I already spent all my support for him when it wasn't very fashionable, so there just isn't much left. Sorry.

I am in the same row of the bus with Source.


My only point lost (and misinterpreted) above was this - last evening, today, hey, things are fun right now, let's just roll joyfully along and save the reality discussions for the long post-season death march. That was my only point.
 
Your making a bet that it would be cheaper to do it now than the end of next season (assuming this team all comes back Willard "hopefully" will have two back to back NCAA's). Realize that's a bold statement but it's less bold/ idiotic than the guys that were posting every other day just two months ago about needing to fire Lyons and Willard.... Really happy to see Willard has finally stuck it to loud minority of people emailing Lyons about wanting him fired. Glad he's proven them wrong and made us relevant again. Great feeling having this team to cheer for and see the seats filled again. Awesome season and hopefully we find a way to play deep in March.
Great post jimmyd. Couldn't agree with you more.
 
This season has been (thus far) beyond a pleasant surprise. But extension? Please...

I have admittedly not been a KW fan, but one great class when hiring an assistant has been the difference. This year has been beyond my expectations and next year if IW doesn't leave could be great... Unless KW can actually follow up with more solid recruits and keep the trajectory, 1-2 plus years doesn't warrant another absurd extension IMO. He still has a lot to prove IMO. Admittedly he seems to have mature some, but it might also be the talent making up for coaching. 1-2 years out of 9-10 as a head coach doesn't make me a blind loyalist...
He got his extension a couple years ago, and as I believe it was a significant length, now he has to go out and recruit past this sophomore class, which he had the help of hiring HS coaches to accomplish!
Hey, I'm a fan of Willard, but prove it over time!
 
I am in the same row of the bus with Source.

My only point lost (and misinterpreted) above was this - last evening, today, hey, things are fun right now, let's just roll joyfully along and save the reality discussions for the long post-season death march. That was my only point.
I hope there's room on the bus. You guys summed it up. Only reason it became a thread was because of Lavin's comments. Enjoy the ride right now (we all know, they don't happen often!!!) and these kind of threads can wait for after the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUSource
I hope there's room on the bus. You guys summed it up. Only reason it became a thread was because of Lavin's comments. Enjoy the ride right now (we all know, they don't happen often!!!) and these kind of threads can wait for after the season.

Yep - I knew you were in that space.

I think we absolutely all of us hope for a wonderful ride this season. It's so much fun.

Best be an epicurean today, given how many years we have been forced to be stoics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUSource
See, I come at it from the opposite direction. He was my first choice when I hired him, and I was a staunch defender well into his fifth season, even as the opinion of many posters changed with the breeze. I say you support a guy (or don't) until it's clear that he doesn't merit that support anymore.

Last year, I was finally forced to concede I had been wrong. It was plainly evident that he was not as good of a coach as I had believed, so my belief was that he should've been let go last year. Now, just as I never changed my mind with the direction of the wind in the first five seasons, I'm not easily swayed now. I don't think coaches just learn how to coach all of a sudden. And there are just too many variables that make the record alone a clear indicator of a coach's ability. Is our record terrific this year? Obviously, and the team is very good. I'm on record here as saying we can, with the right matchups and a few breaks, contend for the Elite Eight. But when our record sucked in 2012-13, I also still contended - loudly - that this guy was a good coach, and that the record alone did not prove otherwise to me. Then, as now, there are too many other factors and variables that told me there was more to consider than just the wins and losses. But as seasons stack up, and I have more and more data to inform my opinion, I realized I had been wrong about what he brings as a head coach. And I haven't seen what I need to see to change my mind. Perhaps if he's still here in four years, and these kinds of seasons (or something similar) have been sustained even as players cycle through the program, I'll again admit I had it wrong. But right now, the scales are still tilted pretty heavily to one side.

Isaiah Whitehead is, right now, playing better than I've ever seen a Seton Hall player play. He's is what we thought he would be, and he is really put the team on his back. Couple that with the sturdy and stabilizing leadership Derrick Gordon brought to the team - I think he literally saved the season after that first Creighton game, when things looked ready to implode again, and there was no Sterling Gibbs to blame. Without his stabilizing presence (to say nothing of the gritty defense tone he set from day one), I'm not sure this team would have been in the position to allow Whitehead to blossom like he has over the past month. Yeah, kids got a year older and all that, but we've seen kids get older for years and never seen a team grow in this same way - even teams led by this head coach. If I was Kevin Willard, I make a spot for Derrick Gordon on the staff next year. He's shown me that much.

So that's where I am with it. I've been careful not to take potshots at the coach this season, even though I do not support him, or piss on threads congratulating him for this or that. He's here for now, and that's that. Wouldn't have been my call, but no one asked me. But there was a post or two last night calling out the silence of the Willard detractors, and I guess I'm identified as one, so here it is for me. This is what I think. It's not really my way to stomp on a win - and of course I want us to win! - so what was I going to say about him last night? I'm also not trying to swim upstream, and there's no point being one of those jerks who can't let it go, and instead makes every post a vehicle for disparaging the coach. But as I said, I'm rooted in my convictions, and I don't change my mind on a coach back and forth over the course of a season, so it would be silly of me to take a posture of reconsideration when I have not changed my mind. We're having a great season, and I'm thrilled. Give the coach a parade? I already spent all my support for him when it wasn't very fashionable, so there just isn't much left. Sorry.

I'm with you. Things may be very different a year from now with the loss of Gordon and potentially Whitehead, but Willard's coaching has undoubtedly improved this season. On court coaching is only part of what it takes to be successful at this level and without improved recruiting it will be very difficult to sustain the success we've had this year.
 
Not allowed to do that on this board any more or so I'll be chastised. Euphoria is short lived. So lets run with it. Sad.
So I can assume this guy

movies-harry-potter-and-the-half-blood-prince-voldemort.jpg


is no longer to be confused with this guy?

USATSI_5820172_149008644_lowres.jpg
 
idk if he deserves it after one 3rd place finish and ncaa appearance. Let's see some consistency first
 
Ah, hard work and long hours. Welcome to the real world. Now if only they were compensated for their long hours.

Hard work does not necessarily equate to success either ... Am I happy about this season? Oh yes I am. And hopefully the success continues for many many many years... But in life if you're a hard-working failure you're still a failure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vegas pj
Hard work does not necessarily equate to success either ... Am I happy about this season? Oh yes I am. And hopefully the success continues for many many many years... But in life if you're a hard-working failure you're still a failure.
BINGO!
 
I will be the first one to say Kevin is a friend. He, Sha and every person on that staff work as hard as anybody. We have an unbelievable staff, even if nobody admits it. If we are lucky, we have Kevin for a long long time
 
I will be the first one to say Kevin is a friend. He, Sha and every person on that staff work as hard as anybody. We have an unbelievable staff, even if nobody admits it. If we are lucky, we have Kevin for a long long time

Absolutely agree. The staff (Lyons included) and the team have worked tirelessly to get us where we are today. The current staff assembled one hell of a team and made us relevant again. Anybody that wants to dismiss that is deluuuuuusssional! I do hope the donations increase with the wins! I seem to remember people only wanting to donate when we were relevant.
 
Last edited:
Willard and Lavin are friendly. So no surprise that Lavin is saying some nice things about him publicly.

SJU didn't play the negative recruiting card with Whitehead - other programs most certainly did, though it had more to do with the state of the program as opposed to Willard's stability. Remember that Lavin wasn't a lock for an extension at that point either, so playing that card would have been useless. SJU sold the NY thing plus Whitehead learning under some very good guards on what was expected to be (and was) a NCAA tourney team (Harrison, Greene, Jordan, Branch, etc) instead of having to be the "man" from the get go.

Either way, as it's been stated before on this board, Whitehead's recruitment to Seton Hall came down to one thing and one thing only - Tiny Morton's job as an assistant coach. That's the reason he came. And it will get Willard the extension he wants.

I love the job Willard has done this year - just thought it was interesting to hear a once rival coach go out of his way to make sure Kevin is taken care of. Correct me if I am wrong but when he was at St. John's didn't he use a lot of negativity about the stability of our program in an effort to keep Whitehead from coming here.
 
What did / does IW get out of his coach getting hired and then leaving after one season? I genuinely don't understand it. I know us hiring Tiny is why IW chose us, and I understand why it benefits Tiny, but why is that what cinches it for the player?
 
Their relationship. Tiny wasn't close enough with a guy like Lance to make that a package deal. Isiah wanted to take care of him, plus it guaranteed that Desi would be in the mix too, who wasn't nearly as highly recruited (and, by the way, thank god for that - he could be Ladonte Henton by the time he is a senior). Tiny got a taste of the college environment and decided it wasn't for him. Plus I think he saw that if Willard was gone, and the Hall promoted internally, Sha was the most logical choice to get the nod.

Had Willard not agreed to add Tiny, Whitehead would have went to St. John's, with Desi likely along for the ride. Tiny would have tried to parlay that into some type of arrangement with Under Armour, which a lot of the top HS and AAU coaches do (SJU has a strong rel'ship with UA).




What did / does IW get out of his coach getting hired and then leaving after one season? I genuinely don't understand it. I know us hiring Tiny is why IW chose us, and I understand why it benefits Tiny, but why is that what cinches it for the player?
 
By the way, on the issue of coaching stability, I know we are using a similar tactic with Thompson and Syracuse. Jimmy B will be gone during Thompson's tenure, and Hopkins, was widely respect as an assistant, is an unknown. We are selling - the ability to stay home, play with a ready-made NCAA team (everyone returns), and the ability to play with an established big like Delgado while not having the same high-level competition at the spot that you'll see at Kansas, Cuse or even Gtown. Providence is selling their development of a kid like Bentil, and Cooley seems to develop a great rapport with kids he targets.

Absolutely agree. The staff (Lyons included) and the team have worked tirelessly to get us where we are today. The current staff assembled one hell of a team and made us relevant again. Anybody that wants to dismiss that is deluuuuuusssional! I do hope the donations increase with the wins! I seem to remember people only wanting to donate when we were relevant.
 
No Willard fan here but he's done a very good job this year so (brken record alert) any coach that you are going to keep has to have 4 years on his contract with appropriate 2-way buyouts.
 
No Willard fan here but he's done a very good job this year so (brken record alert) any coach that you are going to keep has to have 4 years on his contract with appropriate 2-way buyouts.

Well another bingo has to be called.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT