ADVERTISEMENT

Murphy

Politicians know that the more air time they get on TV usually leads to approval and reelections. Trump can't stay on script so he debunks that theory but for the most part those daily briefings are free campaigning and noone has taken advantage as much as Murphy and Cuomo.

Murphy and Cuomo should be getting lambasted for their policies on sending Covid-19 patients to nursing homes during the pandemic. Some outlets are covering it while others are not. That single policy put many elderly nursing home patients in harms way and no doubt boosted the number of deaths at those nursing homes. Neither will admit outright they were wrong although Cuomo started to say it.

The Florida governor got rightfully lambasted for the spring breakers and open beaches. He has not received much credit for shutting down nursing home access early during the pandemic and Florida's numbers prove that was a very good move protecting citizens in the most danger.
 
Politicians know that the more air time they get on TV usually leads to approval and reelections. Trump can't stay on script so he debunks that theory but for the most part those daily briefings are free campaigning and noone has taken advantage as much as Murphy and Cuomo.

Murphy and Cuomo should be getting lambasted for their policies on sending Covid-19 patients to nursing homes during the pandemic. Some outlets are covering it while others are not. That single policy put many elderly nursing home patients in harms way and no doubt boosted the number of deaths at those nursing homes. Neither will admit outright they were wrong although Cuomo started to say it.

The Florida governor got rightfully lambasted for the spring breakers and open beaches. He has not received much credit for shutting down nursing home access early during the pandemic and Florida's numbers prove that was a very good move protecting citizens in the most danger.
https://www.miamiherald.com/news/health-care/article242844471.html
 
Murphy and Cuomo should be getting lambasted for their policies on sending Covid-19 patients to nursing homes during the pandemic. Some outlets are covering it while others are not. That single policy put many elderly nursing home patients in harms way and no doubt boosted the number of deaths at those nursing homes. Neither will admit outright they were wrong although Cuomo started to say it.

Can we walk through this just so I understand the issue there better?

A patient from a nursing home as admitted to a hospital for Covid related issues, they are treated and discharged by the hospital after it is confirmed they are stable. Where should the patient go? Is the criticism that they should not have sent them back to their facility, and should have set up a new post Covid assisted living facility?

Not sure if the larger spread in NY and NJ facilities has more to do with the fact that it got to NJ / NY first so there may have already been rapid spread among the facilities or if it has to do with re-admissions to the facilities. Did PA have the same executive order? They seemed to have a lot of deaths in nursing / assisted living facilities as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Piratz and SPK145
Add Wolf to that list

Lamont in CT has handled this fairly well. He's been reasonable.

Pritzker (IL) and Whitmer (MI) have been even worse than Murphy and Cuomo, if that's possible.
 
The Florida governor got rightfully lambasted for the spring breakers and open beaches. He has not received much credit for shutting down nursing home access early during the pandemic and Florida's numbers prove that was a very good move protecting citizens in the most danger.

I never know what to make of DeSantis in general, but you can't argue the facts. His approach has worked. Amazingly, his approval ratings are lower than others. The sheep don't like him, LOL.
 
Can we walk through this just so I understand the issue there better?

A patient from a nursing home as admitted to a hospital for Covid related issues, they are treated and discharged by the hospital after it is confirmed they are stable. Where should the patient go? Is the criticism that they should not have sent them back to their facility, and should have set up a new post Covid assisted living facility?

Not sure if the larger spread in NY and NJ facilities has more to do with the fact that it got to NJ / NY first so there may have already been rapid spread among the facilities or if it has to do with re-admissions to the facilities. Did PA have the same executive order? They seemed to have a lot of deaths in nursing / assisted living facilities as well.

This is exactly what’s being forgotten, what’s the alternative to what was done? At the time we were in a crunch for hospital space, so if someone is healthy enough to not require hospitalization they had to go home. If they were from a nursing home, then that’s where they had to go back to. It was responsibility of the nursing home to have the proper procedures in place to protect other people. They weren’t prepared for that and many nursing homes failed. That is the real issue.

The only alternatives were to release people to family members, many of which are not equipped to give proper care to elderly people and would be even less safe from a protection standpoint. The other option is to create makeshift nursing homes, which considering the focus at the time was on creating makeshift hospitals for critical care, is understandable that they couldn’t achieve.
 
Add Wolf to that list

Yes, he has been terrible. I've got a horse at PARX just itching to run but no racing in PA even though there is racing just about everywhere else now. Can't ship her to another facility as then we can't bring her back to PARX. So people on the backstretch are not getting paid.
 
Yes, he has been terrible. I've got a horse at PARX just itching to run but no racing in PA even though there is racing just about everywhere else now. Can't ship her to another facility as then we can't bring her back to PARX. So people on the backstretch are not getting paid.
Spk you own thoroughbreds?

What are your thoughts on monmouth?
 
A patient from a nursing home as admitted to a hospital for Covid related issues, they are treated and discharged by the hospital after it is confirmed they are stable. Where should the patient go? Is the criticism that they should not have sent them back to their facility, and should have set up a new post Covid assisted living facility?

Yes.
 

Ok, how long should it take to open a facility like that and staff it with an appropriate level of staff to take care of the residents?
What do you do with the residents who have been discharged by their hospitals while they are setting all of that up?

I don't think it's wrong to question if we did enough. I think we could have done more, but we should also look like what was realistic and possible at the time and should try to also understand where the virus was coming from. Maybe it was the staff who was going out each day and coming back without taking the proper precautions to protect the residents? Maybe the re-admissions had no impact on Covid related deaths, or maybe they had a large impact. We don't really know though at this point.
 
Spk you own thoroughbreds?

What are your thoughts on monmouth?

Monmouth has been run into the ground. I grew up going to Monmouth, won a $250 daily double there in 1975 when I was 14, my father made me open a bank account with the winnings, still have that bank account.

I still love Monmouth but the quality of racing has gone way down except for certain days like Haskell Day. They cut purses years ago for Jersey-breds, decimating the NJ breeding industry. PA is the place to be up until this year. Gov Wolf wants to take $200 million from the horse racing industry even though he himself signed a bill a few years ago saying he couldn't do that.

The physical facility of Monmouth is still nice but it's usually pretty empty even on weekends except for certain race days.

Management tried an elite meet a few years ago with big purses that lured the big-name trainers from all over but it lost lot of money. They tried to go back to normal but most of the long-time stables had left over the elite meet stuff.
 
Can we walk through this just so I understand the issue there better?

A patient from a nursing home as admitted to a hospital for Covid related issues, they are treated and discharged by the hospital after it is confirmed they are stable. Where should the patient go? Is the criticism that they should not have sent them back to their facility, and should have set up a new post Covid assisted living facility?

Not sure if the larger spread in NY and NJ facilities has more to do with the fact that it got to NJ / NY first so there may have already been rapid spread among the facilities or if it has to do with re-admissions to the facilities. Did PA have the same executive order? They seemed to have a lot of deaths in nursing / assisted living facilities as well.
No your definition of the problem is incorrect. Patients that had Covid and had "nothing to do with a particular nursing home" facility were sent to nursing homes to recover and still having Covid. In addition existing patients at a facility who had Covid were sent back. Nursing homes were not equipped (PPE) or prepared to care for them. State guidelines that they came up with during the initial outbreak said "nursing homes cannot refuse to take patients from hospitals solely because they have the coronavirus." Nursing homes were losing staff every day that were either exposed to CV (and had to quarantine) or got CV so their staffing levels were bad and they could not hire new staff. Nursing homes were "not allowed" to refuse patients that were sent to them by order of the governor. Nursing home administrators were livid because they were trying to protect their at risk patients and had no say in what new patients or existing returning patients with Covid they had to take into their home. Some handled it better than others but it no doubt increased the risk significantly for the existing "at-risk" patients. Most had no or inadequate levels of PPE and or the layout of the nursing homes made it difficult to keep Covid patients completely separate from the healthy population. Many homes had to move elderly patients out of their existing rooms to create new spaces for Covid patients. Have you ever cared for an elderly person that is finally used to their new space (it can take months) and then have to move them again? It can be traumatic. My sister runs a home health care agency (25+ years) and works with multiple nursing homes and said they were so upset with this order and their patients were sitting ducks and they had no choice. She told one of her friends to get her mother out of a nursing home because of this policy to protect her because they were taking Covid patients. Just dealing with Covid every day for any HC facility is a challenge but made even harder when new infected patients are being added to the nursing home mix and administrators were not allowed to say no, could not get prepared as they could not aquire more PPE and could not keep their staff healthy putting added pressure on the staff that was there.

There are many stories of NYC nursing homes overrun with Covid patients yet they had the big ship and Javitz center not even close to capacity. Cuomo said they did this so patients would not get discriminated against? How about the existing patients at the home trying to stay healthy? This was a mistake and about 4 states had this policy (NY, NJ, Mass and CA).

If you have access the NY Times here is an article https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/24/us/nursing-homes-coronavirus.html

Here is the AARP take - https://www.aarp.org/caregiving/health/info-2020/coronavirus-transfers-to-nursing-homes.html

NBC https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-new...home-forced-take-recovering-patients-n1191811

This is not a democrat or republican issue. It's an issue of common sense.
 
Last edited:
Monmouth has been run into the ground. I grew up going to Monmouth, won a $250 daily double there in 1975 when I was 14, my father made me open a bank account with the winnings, still have that bank account.

I still love Monmouth but the quality of racing has gone way down except for certain days like Haskell Day. They cut purses years ago for Jersey-breds, decimating the NJ breeding industry. PA is the place to be up until this year. Gov Wolf wants to take $200 million from the horse racing industry even though he himself signed a bill a few years ago saying he couldn't do that.

The physical facility of Monmouth is still nice but it's usually pretty empty even on weekends except for certain race days.

Management tried an elite meet a few years ago with big purses that lured the big-name trainers from all over but it lost lot of money. They tried to go back to normal but most of the long-time stables had left over the elite meet stuff.
Yup ac money stopped and christie didnt wanna give support anymore...monmouth really roared 80s and 90s...is this your only horse is it older?
 
Yup ac money stopped and christie didnt wanna give support anymore...monmouth really roared 80s and 90s...is this your only horse is it older?

Only 1 currently running, 5 year old mare, graded stakes winner.
 
Patients that had Covid and had "nothing to do with a particular nursing home" facility were sent to nursing homes to recover and still having Covid. In addition existing patients at a facility who had Covid were sent back.

Ok, thanks for clarifying. On point 1, I would agree. Where were those people living? Private residence and were sent to a facility to recover? I would agree that was a mistake if so.

On the second point, I don't really agree unfortunately. Just no good answer there.
Can't stay in a hospital indefinitely and they have to go somewhere.

While I can certainly see your argument if you are bringing patients unrelated to a facility and introducing the virus for the first time, but if they were residents of and got Covid at the facility, the lack of PPE is still an issue the ability to have space for quarantine is still an issue... etc.

I think the ideal situation would have been to take over a new facility for those who were confirmed to be infected.
Staff it with people who can care for them accordingly. Not sure how feasible something like that would have been, but hopefully that was considered as an option.

With that said though, I am not sure what impact that would have had if Covid was already spreading within the facilities?

This is not a democrat or republican issue. It's an issue of common sense.

I agree with that but I really wouldn't feel much differently about the nursing homes if a republican was governor.

I was on board with how Murphy handled this originally (with some missteps along the way) but I don't think he is handling the reopening well enough. I think the data available supports reopening NJ at this point.
 
Ok, thanks for clarifying. On point 1, I would agree. Where were those people living? Private residence and were sent to a facility to recover? I would agree that was a mistake if so.

On the second point, I don't really agree unfortunately. Just no good answer there.
Can't stay in a hospital indefinitely and they have to go somewhere.

While I can certainly see your argument if you are bringing patients unrelated to a facility and introducing the virus for the first time, but if they were residents of and got Covid at the facility, the lack of PPE is still an issue the ability to have space for quarantine is still an issue... etc.

I think the ideal situation would have been to take over a new facility for those who were confirmed to be infected.
Staff it with people who can care for them accordingly. Not sure how feasible something like that would have been, but hopefully that was considered as an option.

With that said though, I am not sure what impact that would have had if Covid was already spreading within the facilities?



I agree with that but I really wouldn't feel much differently about the nursing homes if a republican was governor.

I was on board with how Murphy handled this originally (with some missteps along the way) but I don't think he is handling the reopening well enough. I think the data available supports reopening NJ at this point.
Many were simply Covid patients unrelated to the nursing home, not requiring a ICU or a vent. Hospitals were trying to keep those beds for more serious patients or were full so the patients had to go somewhere. Its one thing if it was a fully staffed rehab facility with higher level nursing but they were sending patients unrelated to the nursing home to regular nursing homes in the area. Not smart at all. Many homes had no infections until they received the Covid patients and either the staff or the patients being in the building spread the virus (you can never prove it 100%). There is a reason though why so many states did not do this and they were right. Find another facility that is not filled with the most vulnerable patients and NYC had those extra facilities but chose to send the Covid patients to nursing homes instead of the Javitz center or the medical ship.

And in some cases the lack of PPE was because the nursing homes gave their PPE to the hospitals as they were encouraged to do only to expose their own workers when the Covid patients were sent back to them which they did not expect. When they argued the state health authorities doubled down and said by order you cannot refuse patients.

Not to mention that there is precedent for nursing home patients who develop other conditions (not in a covid environment) that get sent to facilities that are equipped to handle their condition. Many times those patients dont make it back to their original home until they are better or if other accomodations can be made. Should not send patients back to a home just because its their home if it is not equipped to handle them. I understand it was a pandemic but there was a lot of disagreement over this policy all along and NY and NJ should have changed it midstream at minimum especially when they knew hospitals were not overrun. At least adjust, but in both states they did not and they are still doubling down. There are already a number of lawsuits and there are going to be a lot more over this.
 
Last edited:
With that said though, I am not sure what impact that would have had if Covid was already spreading within the facilities?
.
That is not the point. The point is you protect the most vulnerable and as a country we F'd that up in a huge way IMO when you look at how high the percentage is of nursing home deaths.
 
Heard an interview with former N.Y. Governor David Patterson this morning who agreed Cuomo made a big mistake and should accept responsibility instead of the way he tried to blame Trump.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
Just goes to show you how stupid the general public is. They follow the "leader" like the sheep they are. Never question anything.

Look no further than people who think Trump can't do anything wrong and the crazy extreme leftists.

Heard an interview with former N.Y. Governor David Patterson this morning who agreed Cuomo made a big mistake and should accept responsibility instead of the way he tried to blame Trump.

These two points are tied together. Admit nothing. Blame the other party, past Administrations, everyone. Nothing pragmatic, nothing collaborative, nothing related to science or thought, just BS. And Cuomo's pressers went from informative to sermon. Trump's I couldn't even watch they were such trainwrecks and spin cycles.

And if you made a bad tactical decision, point to a billion other factors out of your control that forced you into said decision, usually from the other Party.

It's time to open. The shutdown did help contain this and gave us time to learn a lot more about the virus, it's potency and it's transmission. We are already on the path to catching up with all kinds of testing that will help mitigate any other wave in the future. Keep those most at-risk protected. Let's go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
At least adjust, but in both states they did not and they are still doubling down.

that’s not true though. In NJ, they were not doubling down, they were assessing and updating pretty much every day.

https://www.state.nj.us/health/legal/covid19/

On April 13th, they blocked admissions to facilities that could not separate residents, follow CDC guidelines and maintain adequate staffing.

https://www.state.nj.us/health/legal/covid19/4-13-20_EmergencyCurtailmentOfAdmissions.pdf
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
That is not the point. The point is you protect the most vulnerable and as a country we F'd that up in a huge way IMO when you look at how high the percentage is of nursing home deaths.

Right, it’s clear when we look back that we can say we F’d up.

But the virus made its way into these facilities before any residents were admitted / readmitted and It spreads very easily.

It’s likely that around 15% of the state has been infected.

I’m just asking for what we should have done differently that would have resulted in a better outcome at these facilities. If we introduced the virus to a facility a resident was not associated with, then I agree that was completely the wrong decision... but outside of that, the far majority of residents were likely returning to facilities where the virus was already spreading.
 
Right, it’s clear when we look back that we can say we F’d up.

But the virus made its way into these facilities before any residents were admitted / readmitted and It spreads very easily.

It’s likely that around 15% of the state has been infected.

I’m just asking for what we should have done differently that would have resulted in a better outcome at these facilities. If we introduced the virus to a facility a resident was not associated with, then I agree that was completely the wrong decision... but outside of that, the far majority of residents were likely returning to facilities where the virus was already spreading.
First of all CV patients should have only been sent to facilities with skilled nursing care that were prepared for this (with PPE and full time docs on staff etc). If there was a minimum requirement that should have been at least considered but it wasn't as they were sent to all types of homes. Also nursing homes should have been given advanced notice that this was happening so they could prepare. I know the virus was moving quickly but we knew that in other countries the older population was dying the most - we knew that and should have been overprotective of that population but we missed that sans this policy. And homes that could keep patients on a separate floor or wing from the regular population. And the other patients at the homes should have been notified that this was occuring so families could be in the loop. Many nursing homes had no idea this policy was in place and when they tried to fight it they were told by state authorities take the patients or lose your license.

I'm glad to see Murphy finally changed the policy that is good news. Cuomo hasn't and said it was so Covid patients weren't discriminated against? It's now not as big of an issue because hospitals have tons of capacity but during the crisis period Cuomo and Murphy were questioned countless times about it and did not respond. 4 states did it that is it. Telling as well as to the judgement the other states made. And in NY why wasn't the ship and Javitz center used yet they sent 100s of patients to nursing homes - that is something that Cuomo and Deblasio and their health leaders should answer for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HALL85
4 states did it that is it. Telling as well as to the judgement the other states made. And in NY why wasn't the ship and Javitz center used yet they sent 100s of patients to nursing homes - that is something that Cuomo and Deblasio and their health leaders should answer for.

You can't compare NJ and NY to other states. It got here earlier and was spreading well beyond what we knew of at the time and we were the states facing potential shortages of hospital beds. That wasn’t happening in other states. The deaths here are more likely due to the fact that it was spreading before we started taking additional precautions. Other states had the benefit of seeing what was happening in NY/NJ and were able to prepare.

The ship was brought to New York to treat patients who were not infected in case the hospitals kept seeing the growth in volume they were seeing. Thankfully, we didn't really need the ship. They shifted after a couple weeks to allow covid patients on board.

not saying everything went perfectly but under different presidents and governors this still gets here and speeds similarly.

it’s horrible what happened in nursing homes, but I’m not convinced the outcome would be different had we discharged Covid positive elderly to a quarantined facility.
 
You can't compare NJ and NY to other states. It got here earlier and was spreading well beyond what we knew of at the time and we were the states facing potential shortages of hospital beds. That wasn’t happening in other states. The deaths here are more likely due to the fact that it was spreading before we started taking additional precautions. Other states had the benefit of seeing what was happening in NY/NJ and were able to prepare.

The ship was brought to New York to treat patients who were not infected in case the hospitals kept seeing the growth in volume they were seeing. Thankfully, we didn't really need the ship. They shifted after a couple weeks to allow covid patients on board.

not saying everything went perfectly but under different presidents and governors this still gets here and speeds similarly.

it’s horrible what happened in nursing homes, but I’m not convinced the outcome would be different had we discharged Covid positive elderly to a quarantined facility.
You’re making a lot of assumptions in that post. If they analyzed the data early on, they would have seen the trends. Through the whole epidemic, containment is the first priority to limit spread. Politics took priority over science.
 
You’re making a lot of assumptions in that post. If they analyzed the data early on, they would have seen the trends. Through the whole epidemic, containment is the first priority to limit spread. Politics took priority over science.

revisit your posts from early march.

you’re not an unreasonable person but you were no where near where we would have needed to be.

Unfortunately, no one was taking things seriously enough to do what we would have needed to do to keep it from spreading until it was too late.

and yes, I am making a lot of assumptions as is everyone else here.
 
revisit your posts from early march.

you’re not an unreasonable person but you were no where near where we would have needed to be.

Unfortunately, no one was taking things seriously enough to do what we would have needed to do to keep it from spreading until it was too late.

and yes, I am making a lot of assumptions as is everyone else here.
It’s not about me. I didn’t have access to data nor in the position to make those decisions.
 
It’s not about me. I didn’t have access to data nor in the position to make those decisions.

Selling it to the public is part of the equation.

We would not have accepted what needed to be done when there was 1 reported case in New York.

Had we known them everything we know now, maybe things would have been different. Unfortunately we didn’t know nearly enough then.
 
Selling it to the public is part of the equation.

We would not have accepted what needed to be done when there was 1 reported case in New York.

Had we known them everything we know now, maybe things would have been different. Unfortunately we didn’t know nearly enough then.
Our people/culture not enough discipline
 
You can't compare NJ and NY to other states. It got here earlier and was spreading well beyond what we knew of at the time and we were the states facing potential shortages of hospital beds. That wasn’t happening in other states. The deaths here are more likely due to the fact that it was spreading before we started taking additional precautions. Other states had the benefit of seeing what was happening in NY/NJ and were able to prepare.

The ship was brought to New York to treat patients who were not infected in case the hospitals kept seeing the growth in volume they were seeing. Thankfully, we didn't really need the ship. They shifted after a couple weeks to allow covid patients on board.

not saying everything went perfectly but under different presidents and governors this still gets here and speeds similarly.

it’s horrible what happened in nursing homes, but I’m not convinced the outcome would be different had we discharged Covid positive elderly to a quarantined facility.
You don’t add infected patients to healthy ones at the highest risk in facilities not prepared. That is really it. Sorry you can’t see it and choose to be an apologist for really bad decisions that were made. Washington State had it worse than NY for a time and they didn’t resort to this flawed policy.
 
You don’t add infected patients to healthy ones at the highest risk in facilities not prepared. That is really it. Sorry you can’t see it and choose to be an apologist for really bad decisions that were made. Washington State had it worse than NY for a time and they didn’t resort to this flawed policy.

I’m not an apologist, I’m just trying to understand what the options were at the time.

I read a story about a hospital not wanting to take in patients from a nursing home because they would not be able to discharge them if their home wouldn’t. Take them back in...

It’s not like they saw a great option on the table and ignored it. The biggest focus as many here have agreed was to prevent the hospitals from being completely full. A scenario that was not that far away in parts of NY and NJ.

sometimes there are no good options.
 
Here's an article that states the case better than I can and also sheds a significant light on how we should double down on protecting our most vulnerable going forward (42-43% of deaths from nursing homes and assisted living facilities). The Florida policy makers and Agency for Health Care Administration did a great job protecting their elderly in spite of the overtures from Medicare and bad policies being followed by other states. https://www.forbes.com/sites/theapo...ation-43-of-u-s-covid-19-deaths/#65d5fd1474cd
 
Here's an article that states the case better than I can and also sheds a significant light on how we should double down on protecting our most vulnerable going forward (42-43% of deaths from nursing homes and assisted living facilities). The Florida policy makers and Agency for Health Care Administration did a great job protecting their elderly in spite of the overtures from Medicare and bad policies being followed by other states. https://www.forbes.com/sites/theapo...ation-43-of-u-s-covid-19-deaths/#65d5fd1474cd
I can understand that they wanted to ensure the hospitals had capacity, but in the tri-state area alone, there were make-shift hospitals built or in the process (Javits, SS Comfort, AC Convention Hall, East Stroudsburg University, St. Joe's Philly, etc.) that were barely used if at all. All of those nursing home patients that were positive could have been quarantined or treated there.

Heard a journalist from Florida yesterday that alluded to this being a big difference maker. Also that the vast majority of COVID cases in the state were restricted to Miami-Dade area (elderly and density).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section112
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT