Eh, if Beckham catches it the Pats have all day to stroll down the field for a TD which they inevitably would've done.This was beyond strategy, IMO. Need to catch the ball. End of story. Beckham, Collins, either of them.
Collins obviously should make the play. But bad players generally make bad plays. 10 games into his career he's already shown enough evidence to indicate he's a bad player. Again, he got benched for CRAIG DAHL! There's only one person on Earth who thinks Craig Dahl is an NFL player. Unfortunately that person is the Giants general manager.