Slow Day So Here's a Top 10 List
- Thread starter JRSlim2284
- Start date
I don't hate it.
I'd probably have several players ahead of Mamu if I'm being honest though.
I'd probably have several players ahead of Mamu if I'm being honest though.
Myles Powell and Markus Howard were the very poor mans version of Magic and Bird so they need to be right next to each other. If I am not mistaken Powell and the Pirates mostly got the best of them so would give Powell the nod for better player.
Whitehead used to out play Dunn and Whiteheads team won the Big East therefore I would put him over Dunn.
That is just talking seton hall. I think there are a lot of good players that have been overlooked.
Whitehead used to out play Dunn and Whiteheads team won the Big East therefore I would put him over Dunn.
That is just talking seton hall. I think there are a lot of good players that have been overlooked.
Damned right!! SHU talking!
The MQ BET game when the staff thought Myles was kicked out for two Ts was one of the most fun games I ever saw. When he came back to the bench, MSG went wild. Lots of MQ fans were I was sitting and it was getting kinda edgy. Was wishing Prof ed was with me lol! Myles shoulda been BET MVP his Jr year and Markus his Sr yr. But at least both got one award.
Also as a college player Rhoden was more impactful then Sandro and they both leaned on a walk on named Shavar from time to time. Personally I dont think Sandro makes this list. As we have seen Sandro had the best potential to be an NBA player but from the College perspective his impact wasnt as great as others.
Brunson is #1 IMO.
I agree with others on Rhoden > Mamu.
Blueitt is the name I've seen the most on Reddit
I agree with others on Rhoden > Mamu.
Blueitt is the name I've seen the most on Reddit
I might put Powell higher on that list IMO.
I wouldn't have Mamu in my top 10. I think there is lots of ways you can go there.
It's an odd dynamic because many of the best player don't stay anywhere close to 4 years, of course, so that is going to impact how one looks at a list like this.
I wouldn't have Mamu in my top 10. I think there is lots of ways you can go there.
It's an odd dynamic because many of the best player don't stay anywhere close to 4 years, of course, so that is going to impact how one looks at a list like this.
If Whitehead played another year he would be on the list. I loved him at SHU and he was a complete stud but IMO he is not on the list. His heroics in the Villanova BE Championship were simply amazing. He took over that game.
Blueitt and Kalkbrenner were my thoughts for #10. I'd have both ahead of Mamu for sure. Would probably have them above Kolek and arguably Carter (just because of only playing 2 years in the BE though - he was phenomenal this year) as well.
Blueitt was a 3 time All Big East first team selection. He was on an All American team at least once I think maybe twice. I would definitely put him in the top 10 when I think about it.
lol. I said to my son we might have to fight our way outa here tonight.
I would put a 3 team first team All BE selection over Mamu and Carter. Agree on Kaulk because his defensive value.
No Gtown or Johnnies nor should there be when you consider the timeframe. I can’t recall if Gtown even had a multi-year first team All Big East player during those years. SJU had Ponds and Champagnie who I think made all BE first team multiple years but aren’t on the level of the top 10 career wise as those on that list.
