I would think the same latitude should be given if they started at the same starting points. Do you really think Sha and Willard started at the same starting points? Do we have any players charged with carrying a gun like Willard was left with in Theodore? Do we have any players with the history of Pope we need to watch. I'm all for same latitude, but because of Willard, Sha can focus on basketball all day every day. Willard didn't get that luxury when he started. Let's be fair nobody here had any real latitude for Willard. The administration did. So people giving it to Sha early in year 2 is no different than Willard would have gotten excpet I think he started 15-2 and then the streak hit. But if he was 0-4 vs power conference teams he would've been ripped here year 2 as well.
If Pope, Theodore, Keon Lawrence, name anyone you want was such a black eye on the university, why didn’t Seton Hall and Willard cut bait from day 1 and just work solely on the image of the team / program and start fresh. Yes it would have been even uglier than it was, but it would have fit the narrative a lot better.
Do I think Willard left Seton Hall in a better place image wise when he left. Absolutely!! We were a respectable name again, we’re recognized for many of the successes that have been pointed out by others.
But in terms of forward thinking, NO.
He did not champion the cause of NIL for Seton Hall as it was being introduced to the college basketball landscape.
He also become reliant solely on transfers to restock his roster. He had the majority of his success with the Whitehead group, Powell, Cale, Rhoden, and Sandro while supplementing those players with transfers that worked out well. (McKnight and Gill)
But by the end of his tenure his best HS recruit after Rhoden was Tyrese Samuel and was paired with the likes of Anthony Nelson, Darnell Brodie, Jahari Long, Domingus Stevens, Tyler Powell, Ryan Conway, and Brandon Weston.
He continued to supplement the roster with transfers. But he wasn’t hitting as many home runs: Aiken (injury issues) Yetna (injury issues, Takal Molson, Jamir Harris, and dare I say Taurean Thompson.
Sha last year had Kadary, Samuel, Harris, and Tray Jackson. He had to go piece his roster together himself with a limited NIL budget in a very short time.
If you compare the talent of Willard year 1 left over vs Sha year 1 left over. I think most would take the Gonzo holdover based on basketball talent alone.