You have to understand that coaches rarely allow vistitors to practice. So Jerry and I can only post what we see with the proviso that is only one viewing. Difficult to be accurate under those circumstance although I respectfully offer Jerry and I are correct far more than we are wrong.
Last season for instance I noted that Bediako played very well when I saw him and EHE struggled. I watched that practice after being told EHE was the better player. He was not and Bediako became a find.
Same with Gil when I saw him in his sitout year. Absolutely loved him.
Remember Q? Watched him once and said he would be our starting PG and was far better than his rating.
Then there is the Veer situation. I thought the Pirates had a major find, but I was wrong.
Watching a player once is no guarantee to correctly profile said player. But Jerry and I do our best to inform our readers.