Oof...never realized he was this bad.
Trea Turner is a bad shortstop. Demonstrably bad. Analytically bad. Empirically bad.
Edmundo Sosa is an excellent shortstop. Entering this weekend’s series in Baltimore, he has 95th-percentile range, a strong arm, and, unlike Turner, uncanny instincts. He can hit a bit, too.
Sosa has done everything to earn the
Phillies’ starting shortstop job. Turner has done everything to lose it.
Turner was the second-worst defensive shortstop in the major leagues in 2023, according to
Baseball Savant. He was, at times, the absolute worst shortstop in the major leagues in 2022. He spent this spring working on his defensive shortcomings, and he improved over 2023; he now merely is well below average, matching his 2022 performance level.
Frankly, he hasn’t been very good for the last five years.
Look, I like Turner. I think he’s a valuable player.
But Turner should not be playing shortstop. Not on a team with one of the best pitching staffs in baseball. Not on a team with championship aspirations.
Turner hasn't been a good shortstop in half a decade. Sosa is elite. Phillies pitchers deserve the best defense they can get. Robin Yount, Chipper Jones, and Mookie Betts all made the move.
www.inquirer.com