ADVERTISEMENT

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

I myself am not advocating Mara selling the team. I do not believe that he falls under the same umbrella as Woody Johnson or Dan Snyder who would be better off.

What I will say is that the Giants have been arguably the worst operated franchise in the NFL in the last 15 years. I cannot think of a franchise that has fallen from such a lofty perch to where they are today.

And it is not just on the field but off the field too. Tearing down Giants Stadium and building MetLife, a downgrade in just about every single way except in luxury amenities, while financing it through PSLs may have made the team more money, but in all other respects it was a historic boondoggle that left the franchise worse off. Remember when the Giants had a 25 year waiting list for season tickets? Having Giants season tickets was a point of pride, passed down from generation to generation. That's all gone now.

I think that Mara is a well intentioned man who is as passionate as a fan as anyone. It must be killing him that he has tried and failed to turn this team around. But if he truly wants to turn things around and bring the Giants to where they were before, then he needs to do some serious soul-searching and accounting of the decisions made over the last 15 years that have led up to this point.
Jaguars, Panthers, Raiders, Bears, Jets, Dolphins, for the most part the Browns, for 50 years until recently the Lions. Those are all franchises that are run much worse than the Giants. Losing doesn’t always mean you’re a bad organization.

He made two bad coaching hires in Shurmur and Joe Judge. It’s unfortunate it happened back to back. They picked a QB that didn’t work out. Those things happen to nearly every franchise. Even the much maligned Dave Gettleman made some good draft picks looking back. There’s nothing that screams he needs to sell the team. So I just don’t get why fans act like it’s some miracle cure. And when pressed on it nobody ever has a good response to why or how selling fixes things.

Sham cronyism

He tried to be a construction worker, was a bell hop at a hotel, owed whitey bulger money, never paid him back and the ferrtita bros installed him as ufc pres after they purchased majority ownership of the company

White got the Ferritta brothers to purchase the UFC specifically so While could rebuild it.
Seriously not going to give credit to him for rebuilding the UFC which was about to go bankrupt into a multi billion dollar company?

I'm not even a fan of the UFC but come on...

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

It unfortunately happens. What franchise in any sport doesn’t go thru down periods? Changing ownership does next to nothing to fix it. Unless there’s true evidence of incompetence (such as the jets story about madden ratings).

As far as we know Mara has done nothing remotely close that.

I myself am not advocating Mara selling the team. I do not believe that he falls under the same umbrella as Woody Johnson or Dan Snyder who would be better off.

What I will say is that the Giants have been arguably the worst operated franchise in the NFL in the last 15 years. I cannot think of a franchise that has fallen from such a lofty perch to where they are today.

And it is not just on the field but off the field too. Tearing down Giants Stadium and building MetLife, a downgrade in just about every single way except in luxury amenities, while financing it through PSLs may have made the team more money, but in all other respects it was a historic boondoggle that left the franchise worse off. Remember when the Giants had a 25 year waiting list for season tickets? Having Giants season tickets was a point of pride, passed down from generation to generation. That's all gone now.

I think that Mara is a well intentioned man who is as passionate as a fan as anyone. It must be killing him that he has tried and failed to turn this team around. But if he truly wants to turn things around and bring the Giants to where they were before, then he needs to do some serious soul-searching and accounting of the decisions made over the last 15 years that have led up to this point.
  • Like
Reactions: Section112

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

This isn't a post-Eli slump. The Giants have had two winning seasons since 2012. Even when Eli was with the team and having arguably most productive (individually) offensive years from 2012-2015 they were below .500 most of that stretch.
It unfortunately happens. What franchise in any sport doesn’t go thru down periods? Changing ownership does next to nothing to fix it. Unless there’s true evidence of incompetence (such as the jets story about madden ratings).

As far as we know Mara has done nothing remotely close that.

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

Please not this nonsense again. What does selling the team do? Some sort of billionaire football genius out there nobody knows about?

Both Daboll and Schoen were very highly thought of before they were hired. They didn’t hire incompetent people. Sometimes it’s bad luck.

How many franchises succeed after losing a generational franchise QB? It takes time and luck. How are the colts, patriots, Saints, Steelers doing the last 5 or more years?

Did those owners become idiots overnight too?

Did the Hunt family in KC finally figure out the secret to football after 50 years or did they get lucky with a QB and coach available at the right time. By your logic they should’ve sold the team a long time ago.

I guess Mara just decided he doesn’t care anymore after the team went to 5 super bowls in 25 years. Sure.

Such made up hysteria.

This isn't a post-Eli slump. The Giants have had two winning seasons since 2012. Even when Eli was with the team and having arguably most productive (individually) offensive years from 2012-2015 they were below .500 most of that stretch.
  • Like
Reactions: TomD82

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

Please not this nonsense again. What does selling the team do? Some sort of billionaire football genius out there nobody knows about?

Both Daboll and Schoen were very highly thought of before they were hired. They didn’t hire incompetent people. Sometimes it’s bad luck.

How many franchises succeed after losing a generational franchise QB? It takes time and luck. How are the colts, patriots, Saints, Steelers doing the last 5 or more years?

Did those owners become idiots overnight too?

Did the Hunt family in KC finally figure out the secret to football after 50 years or did they get lucky with a QB and coach available at the right time. By your logic they should’ve sold the team a long time ago.

I guess Mara just decided he doesn’t care anymore after the team went to 5 super bowls in 25 years. Sure.

Such made up hysteria.
John mara was not the owner then. His father was principle and later split with tisch dad.

Faith Restored! Masonius and Eads lead Pirates to first 4-0 start

  • Like
Reactions: Halldan1 and Harty9

There’s A Game Tomorrow

So short -sighted from so many angles.
Don't get to know the Team so as to increase rooting interests. Why give money to something few have any information about ?
This failure of Sha to disperse information --to allow other contacts-- can and should be handled byhis Bosses ( presuming he has Bosses). It really is an easily fixed problem.

Time for Mara and Tisch to sell

I think the ultimate screw up was absolutely ruining any relationship with Coughlin

He is a good football man, legend coach, and connection to the Giants glory days past and present

Even if they didn’t want him coaching anymore..he should have been given more respect and kept the relationship strong and move him upstairs (he did a good job in Jacksonville) and let him be the football czar until he didn’t want to do it anymore
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT