Pointed out to you a few back ups that are winning games after you said there were none. With HORRIFIC QB play the Giants were close I'm alot of games. GM malpractice to not give the rest of the roster a chance to win to prop up his abysmal decision to extend Jones. Tons of options were out there and he spent 5 million on Locke who cannot get on the field.
Darnold and Wilson are starters….. Wilson was hurt to start the year. Come on man. I literally provided an up to date list.
Vikings drafted McCarthy and were allowing there to be an actual competition for the QB1 job. Fair enough if you want to say Darmold was a starter, but he was not a cemented number 1 and before he got hurt, McCarthy was seriously challenging for the job. Jones has never had to compete for the job with the Giants.
I think you have Lock just in case the team did well and then DJ got hurt near an important game or during an important game. Obviously, that isn't going to happen. At this point Tommy is more appealing as far as lending a storyline to the remaining games. Lock is kind of bland. Tough spot on how to compensate the backup and that I agree with you on.
Team has a better chance of winning games with Devito which is why Daboll is playing him. Daboll is coaching for his job. I personally think Schoen is already cooked and out.
You have NO IDEA what you’re talking about. They’re starting Devito because they’re interested in seeing if he can be a backup next year. Drew Lock is here on a 1 year deal and will not be back no matter what. If the Giants were 8-2 and Jones got hurt. Lock would 100% starting in Sunday. But yeah it’s Schoens fault says the uninformed fan!!!
Yes the giants were making this change regardless of the panthers result. It’s all about an injury guarantee in Daniel Jones contract that they are making sure doesn’t kick in and screw them next year.
Seriously, you think Schoen is happy with Daboll decision to start Devito over the qb he signed to be the back up?
It’s not organizational failure; They have bad quarterback play.. it’s kinda like having bad PG play even tho both are very experienced.. see what I did there?
There are certainly enough draft whiffs. You have to be really overconfident in them to allow them to make the decision. If they get it wrong you are just getting stuck in the same cycle in 3 years. Who knows? Maybe the plan is to not draft a QB and tank for 2026.
Plus, when you have these issues, your team must have good special teams, be disciplined, not make errors. All of that results from good coaching. The giants make tons of mental errors and stupid penalties. Daboll has done a poor job since year 1 in that respect.
And Hard Knocks made it very clear that Mara was skeptical of the Schoen decision regarding Barkley. The I will sign one of you and franchise the other approach Schoen used was Bush league and not downs you treat two of the leaders of the roster.
Schoen extended Jones 2 years and possibly 4. He did pick his QB.
I hear you, but there is more to the story. On an offensively challenged team with a struggling QB, I can recall 2 of our biggest plays from scrimmage where our receivers actually got yards after the catch, being called back due to an OL down the field. We had a TE TD called back because of a similar penalty. Well coached teams don't have those issues. Similarly, defensive flaws were overshadowed by the sacks early in year. However, D gives up huge play after huge play on the ground because of lack of line discipline. Defensive secondary has so many blown coverages. Finally, we have guys being called out for lack of effort including our drafted CB 1 being benched.
