Who saw the end of Georgetown TCU ? Players steps out of bounds as he jacks a three as time expired. Ref standing right there is looking at the ball leave his hand with plenty of time, and not at his foot. Reply declares the shot counts since there was not rule in out of bounds during live action, therefore that can not be changed.
Rule needs to change
- Thread starter Bluebeard
- Start date
Cooley is a classy guy. I always say that a single call doesn't define the outcome, but it's hard to swallow the result of a missed call at the end of a game. Perhaps changing the rule so that every call, or non-call, in the final 60 seconds can be reviewed, would solve the problem.
I understand him praising the refs, but the guy blew the call. He was standing right there and was looking up when the player was clearly right near the line. So is the clock the only thing to review there? That's an automatic review, right, the official doesn't have to ask for that. It was clearly out of his hand for a second, so why even go to the monitor???By the rule stating no official said he was out of bounds, so we can't even look at that on the monitor, is crazy.
So the logic above is as if the official said he was out of bounds and they went to the monitor and see that he wasn't, but the ball left his hand after the clock went to zero, would that still be good? Very stupid rule.
So the logic above is as if the official said he was out of bounds and they went to the monitor and see that he wasn't, but the ball left his hand after the clock went to zero, would that still be good? Very stupid rule.
The guy was out of bounds. You cannot blow calls like that that literally change the outcome of the game in this day and age with the technology, IMO. It's too obvious. We know in 15 seconds sitting on our couch.
Only the NCAA would permit review as to whether the shot was for 3 or 2 but not whether the shooter was OOB.
Replays are used to get it right. I understand you can't check everything, but why not give coaches the same choices to ask for a review? Why have replays if you can't get the call right?
This was an end of regulation scenario. What gets validated is was the shot released before time expired. The closest ref is looking for that not where the feet of the player are going. It is up to the full crew on the floor to act as a check and balance system. It was missed.
Cracks me up. 3 refs reviewing the play and there’s an egregious OOB yet nobody can use common sense and call it. What a world.
Any uproar should go to nabc and ncaa...they have rule changes every year...they can take this up
Suppose the replay shows a gu guy tripped a guy? Is the whole play up for review? I agree last night was bad.
That's my point. If the play will always be reviewed to check if it left his hand before time expired, why is the ref looking at that? The player was in the air reaching for the ball heading out of bounds. THAT's what the ref should be looking at.
Since officials know they can review the shot to confirm/deny whether he got it off on time, the near official shouldn't even be watching the shot and he should've seen the guy step out of bounds. Gtown got screwed. Anyway, if you can review whether a shot got off in time to affect the outcome of a game, you need to be able to review all non-judgement end of game calls to make sure you get the outcome correct.
Referees can’t overturn TCU’s controversial buzzer-beater over Georgetown despite video replay
By Dan Martin
Referees can’t overturn TCU’s controversial buzzer-beater over Georgetown despite video replay
Although replays showed Miller got the shot off before the buzzer, they also showed he stepped on the right sideline before he took the shot, meaning the Horned Frogs should have lost possession.
nypost.com
What failed to be mentioned was the trailing ref did not do his job. Should have been looking at the player and seeing if he was in bounds instead of looking and calling a 3 point shot slightly past halfcourt.Referees can’t overturn TCU’s controversial buzzer-beater over Georgetown despite video replay
By Dan Martin
Referees can’t overturn TCU’s controversial buzzer-beater over Georgetown despite video replay
Although replays showed Miller got the shot off before the buzzer, they also showed he stepped on the right sideline before he took the shot, meaning the Horned Frogs should have lost possession.
There were two lead officials to make the obvious call. Anybody know who the ref was. Horrible job .
How many times at Hall games have we seen a player being called out of bounds on the offensive end. Also spoke to a few HS refs, friends of mine, who do not like to call out other refs but agreed the ref did not do his job in that situation and where he was located on the court.
Similar threads
